This is the multi-page printable view of this section. Click here to print.

Return to the regular view of this page.

Redshift

Protector for Amazon Redshift.

This section describes the high-level architecture of the product on AWS for integration with Amazon Redshift, the installation procedures, and provides guidance on performance. This section focuses on Protegrity-specific aspects and should be consumed with corresponding Redshift documentation.

This guide may also be used with the Protegrity Enterprise Security Administrator Guide, which explains the mechanism for managing the data security policy.

1 - Overview

Solution overview and features.

    Solution Overview

    Amazon Redshift Protector is a cloud native, serverless product for fine-grained data protection with Redshift™, a managed Cloud data warehouse. This enables invocation of the Protegrity data protection cryptographic methods from the Redshift SQL execution context. The benefits of serverless include rapid auto-scaling, performance, low administrative overhead, and reduced infrastructure costs compared to a server-based solution.

    This product provides data protection services invoked by External User Defined Functions (UDFs) within Amazon Redshift. The UDFs act as a client transmitting micro-batches of data to the serverless Protegrity Lambda function. User queries may generate hundreds or thousands of parallel requests to perform security operations. Protegrity’s serverless function is designed to scale and yield reliable query performance under such load.

    Amazon Redshift Protector utilizes a data security policy maintained by an Enterprise Security Administrator (ESA), similar to other Protegrity products. Using regular SQL database queries or tools, such as, Tableau™, authorized users can perform de-identification (protect) and re-identification (unprotect) operations on data within the managed Cloud data warehouse. A user’s individual capabilities are subject to privileges and policies defined by the Enterprise Security Administrator.

    The following data ingestion patterns are available with your managed Cloud data warehouse:

    • Data protection at source applications: In this case, sensitive data is already de-identified (protected) across the enterprise wherever it resides, including the managed data warehouse. Protected data can be ingested directly into your managed Cloud data warehouse. Depending on usage patterns, this ensures that your managed data warehouse is not brought into scope for PCI, PII, GDPR, HIPPA, and other compliance policies.
    • Data protection using the Extract-Transform-Load (ETL) pattern: In this case, sensitive data may be transformed with a Protegrity protector either on-premise or in the Cloud before it is ingested into Redshift.
    • Data protection using the Extract-Load-Transform (ELT) pattern: In this case, sensitive data is protected after it lands into the target system typically through a temporary landing table. It uses the native data warehouse’s compute engine with Protegrity to protect incoming data at very high throughput rates. After the data is protected, the intermediate loading tables are dropped as part of the ingestion workflow.

    Analytics on Protected Data

    Protegrity’s format and length preserving tokenization scheme make it possible to perform analytics directly on protected data. Tokens are join-preserving so protected data can be joined across datasets. Often statistical analytics and machine learning training can be performed without the need to re-identify protected data. However, a user or service account with authorized security policy privileges may re-identify subsets of data using the Redshift Protector on AWS service.

    Features

    Amazon Redshift Protector incorporates Protegrity’s patent-pending vaultless tokenization capabilities into cloud-native serverless technology. Combined with an ESA security policy, Protegrity provides the following features:

    • Fine grained field-level protection in the managed Cloud data warehouse
    • Role-based access control (RBAC) to protect and unprotect (re-identify) data depending on the user privileges
    • Policy enforcement features of other Protegrity application protectors.

    For more information about the available protection options, such as, data types, Tokenization or Encryption types, or length preserving and non-preserving tokens, refer to Protection Methods Reference.

    2 - Architecture

    Deployment architecture and connectivity

      Protector Deployment Architecture

      The Protegrity product should be deployed in the customer’s Cloud account within the same AWS region as the Redshift cluster. The product incorporates Protegrity’s vaultless tokenization engine within an AWS Lambda Function. The encrypted data security policy from an ESA is deployed periodically as a static resource through an AWS Lambda Layer. The policy is decrypted in memory at runtime within the Lambda. This architecture allows Protegrity to be highly available and scale very quickly without direct dependency on any other Protegrity services.

      The product exposes a remote data protection service invoked from external User Defined Functions (UDFs), a native feature of specific Cloud databases. The UDFs can be invoked through direct SQL queries or database views. The external UDF makes parallel calls to the serverless Protegrity Lambda function to perform protect and unprotect data operations. Each network REST request includes a micro-batch of data to process and a secure context header generated by the database with the username and a Protegrity context header with the data element type, and operation to perform. The product applies the ESA security policy including user authorization and returns a corresponding response.

      The security policy is synchronized through another serverless component called the Protegrity Policy Agent. The agent operates on a configurable schedule, fetches the policy from the ESA, performs additional envelope encryption using Amazon KMS, and deploys the policy into the Lambda Layer used by the serverless product. This solution can be configured to automatically provision the static policy or the final step can be performed on-demand by an administrator. The policy takes effect immediately for all new requests. There is no downtime for users during this process.

      The following diagram shows the high-level architecture described above.

      The following diagram shows a reference architecture for synchronizing the security policy from ESA.

      The Protegrity Policy Agent requires network access to an Enterprise Security Administrator (ESA). Most organizations install the ESA on-premise. Therefore, it is recommended that the Policy Agent is installed into a private subnet with a Cloud VPC using a NAT Gateway to enable this communication through a corporate firewall.

      The ESA is a soft appliance that must be pre-installed on a separate server. It is used to create and manage security policies.

      For more information about installing the ESA, and creating and managing policies, refer the Policy Management Guide.

      Log Forwarding Architecture

      Audit logs are by default sent to CloudWatch as long as the function’s execution role has the necessary permissions. The Protegrity Product can also be configured to send audit logs to ESA. Such configuration requires deploying Log Forwarder component which is available as part of Protegrity Product deployment bundle. The diagram below shows additional resources deployed with Log Forwarder component.

      The log forwarder component includes Amazon Kinesis data stream and the forwarder Lambda function. Amazon Kinesis stream is used to batch audit records before sending them to forwarder function, where similar audit logs are aggregated before sending to ESA. Aggregation rules are described in the Protegrity Log Forwarding guide. When the protector function is configured to send audit logs to log forwarder, audit logs are aggregated on the protector function before sending to Amazon Kinesis. Due to specifics of the Lambda runtime lifecycle, audit logs may take up to 15 minutes before being sent to Amazon Kinesis. Protector function exposes configuration to minimize this time which is described in the protector function installation section.

      The security of audit logs is ensured by using HTTPS connection on each link of the communication between protector function and ESA. Integrity and authenticity of audit logs is additionally checked on log forwarder which verifies individual logs signature. The signature verification is done upon arrival from Amazon Kinesis before applying aggregation. If signature cannot be verified, the log is forwarded as is to ESA where additional signature verification can be configured. Log forwarder function uses client certificate to authenticate calls to ESA.

      To learn more about individual audit log entry structure and purpose of audit logs, refer to Audit Logging section in this document. Installation instructions can be found in Audit Log Forwarder installation.

      The audit log forwarding requires network access from the cloud to the ESA. Most organizations install the ESA on-premise. Therefore, it is recommended that the Log Forwarder Function is installed into a private subnet with a Cloud VPC using a NAT Gateway to enable this communication through a corporate firewall.

      Redshift Connectivity

      The AWS Redshift system is a cloud data warehouse Platform-as-a-Service (PaaS) from AWS. Unlike traditional (on-prem or customer-managed) data warehouses and RDBMS systems, Redshift is a fully managed, multi-tenant PaaS service, where the customers do not have the ability to install 3rd party software within the Redshift infrastructure.

      Currently, the Redshift architecture does not allow installing Protegrity data protection UDFs and policy enforcement point (PEP) agents inside the Redshift infrastructure. Therefore, a remote-coupling integration mechanism where Redshift invokes RESTful APIs exposed by the Protegrity product is used.

      Redshift supports remote invocations to the Protegrity infrastructure through External Functions, which in turn calls AWS Lambda.

      Access and authorization between various AWS services involved in this architecture is achieved through Identity Access Management (IAM). For instance, Redshift is given an IAM role to call Lambda, Lambda is given an IAM role to call Secrets Manager, etc. Various IAM role configuration settings are shown in the appendices of this document.

      The following figure illustrates the Protegrity Redshift Integration architecture.

      2.1 -

      Redshift Connectivity

      The AWS Redshift system is a cloud data warehouse Platform-as-a-Service (PaaS) from AWS. Unlike traditional (on-prem or customer-managed) data warehouses and RDBMS systems, Redshift is a fully managed, multi-tenant PaaS service, where the customers do not have the ability to install 3rd party software within the Redshift infrastructure.

      Currently, the Redshift architecture does not allow installing Protegrity data protection UDFs and policy enforcement point (PEP) agents inside the Redshift infrastructure. Therefore, a remote-coupling integration mechanism where Redshift invokes RESTful APIs exposed by the Protegrity product is used.

      Redshift supports remote invocations to the Protegrity infrastructure through External Functions, which in turn calls AWS Lambda.

      Access and authorization between various AWS services involved in this architecture is achieved through Identity Access Management (IAM). For instance, Redshift is given an IAM role to call Lambda, Lambda is given an IAM role to call Secrets Manager, etc. Various IAM role configuration settings are shown in the appendices of this document.

      The following figure illustrates the Protegrity Redshift Integration architecture.

      3 - Installation

      Instructions for installing Protect Service, Policy Agent, and Log Forwarder.

      3.1 - Prerequisites

      Requirements before installing the protector.

        AWS Services

        The following table describes the AWS services that may be a part of your Protegrity installation.

        Service

        Description

        Lambda

        Provides serverless compute for Protegrity protection operations and the ESA integration to fetch policy updates or deliver audit logs.

        KMS

        Provides secrets for envelope policy encryption/decryption for Protegrity.

        Secrets Manager

        Provides secrets management for the ESA credentials.

        S3

        Intermediate storage location for the encrypted ESA policy layer.

        Kinesis

        Required if Log Forwarder is to be deployed. Amazon Kinesis is used to batch audit logs sent from protector function to ESA.

        VPC & NAT Gateway

        Optional. Provides a private subnet to communicate with an on-prem ESA.

        CloudWatch

        Application and audit logs, performance monitoring, and alerts. Scheduling for the policy agent.

        ESA Version Requirements

        The Protector and Log Forwarder functions require a security policy from a compatible ESA version.

        The table below shows compatibility between different Protector and ESA versions.

        Protector VersionESA Version
        8.x9.09.1 & 9.210.0
        2.xNoYes*No
        3.0.x & 3.1.xNoNoYesNo
        3.2.xNoNoYes*
        4.0.xNoNoNoYes

        Legend

        Yes

        Protector was designed to work with this ESA version

        No

        Protector will not work with this ESA version

        *

        Backward compatible policy download supported:

        • Data elements and features which are common between this and previous ESA versions will be downloaded
        • Data elements and features which are new to this ESA version and do not exist in previous ESA version will not be downloaded

        Prerequisites

        RequirementsDescription
        Protegrity distribution and installation scriptsThese artifacts are provided by Protegrity
        Protegrity ESA 10.0+The Cloud VPC must be able to obtain network access to the ESA
        AWS AccountRecommend creating a new sub-account for Protegrity Serverless
        Redshift cluster (Enterprise Edition)Must be in the same region as Protegrity Protect Lambda

        Required Skills and Abilities

        RequirementsDescription
        AWS Account AdministratorTo run CloudFormation (or perform steps manually), create/configure a VPC and IAM permissions.
        Protegrity AdministratorThe ESA credentials required to extract the policy for the Policy Agent
        Redshift AdministratorAccount Admin access required to setup access
        Network AdministratorTo open firewall to access ESA and evaluate AWS network setup

        What’s Next

        3.2 - Pre-Configuration

        Configuration steps before installing the protector.

          Provide AWS sub-account

          Identify or create an AWS account where the Protegrity solution will be installed. It is recommended that a new AWS sub-account be created. This can provide greater security controls and help avoid conflicts with other applications that might impact regional account limits. An individual with the Cloud Administrator role will be required for some subsequent installation steps.

          AWS Account ID: ___________________

          AWS Region (AwsRegion): ___________________

          Determine AWS Region

          Determine the AWS region where the Amazon Redshift cluster is running. This is the region in where the Protegrity solution must be installed.

          AWS Region (AccountRegion): ___________________

          Create S3 bucket for Installing Artifacts

          This S3 bucket will be used for the artifacts required by the CloudFormation installation steps. This S3 bucket must be created in the region that is defined in Provide AWS sub-account

          1. Sign in to the AWS Management Console and open the Amazon S3 console.

          2. Change region to the one determined in Provide AWS sub-account

          3. Click Create Bucket.

          4. Enter a unique bucket name:

            For example, protegrity-install.us-west-2.example.com

          5. Upload the installation artifacts to this bucket. Protegrity will provide the following three artifacts:

            • protegrity-protect-<version>.zip
            • protegrity-agent-<version>.zip
            • protegrity-external-extension-<version>.zip
            • protegrity-sample-policy-<version>.zip

            S3 Bucket name (ArtifactS3Bucket): ___________________

          Create KMS Key

          The Amazon Key Management Service (KMS) provides the ability for the Protegrity Serverless solution to encrypt and decrypt the Protegrity Security Policy.

          To create KMS key:

          1. In the AWS sub-account where the KMS key will reside, select the region.

          2. Navigate to Key Management Service > Create Key.

          3. Configure the key settings:

            • Key type: Asymmetric
            • Key usage: Encrypt and decrypt
            • Key spec: RSA_4096
            • Click Next
          4. Create alias and optional description, such as, Protegrity-Serverless and click Next.

          5. Define key administrative permissions, the IAM user who will administrate the key.

          6. Click Next.

          7. Define the key usage permissions.

          8. In Other AWS accounts, enter the AWS account id used for the Protegrity Serverless installation.

          9. Continue on to create the key. If there is a concern this permission is overly broad, then you can return later to restrict access to the role of two Protegrity Serverless Lambda as principals. Click to open the key in the list and record the ARN.

            KMS Key ARN (AWS_KMS_KEY_ID): ___________________

          10. Download the public key from the KMS key. Navigate to the key in KMS console, select the Public key tab, and click Download. Save the PEM file. This public key will be added to the ESA data store as an export key. Refer to Exporting Keys to Datastore for instructions on adding the public key to the data store.

            KMS Public Key PEM file: ___________________

          Create IAM Account Role

          An IAM role is used to authorize Redshift to access the future Protect Lambda resource.

          To create IAM account role:

          1. From the AWS console, access IAM, select Roles and then Create Role.

          2. In Trusted entity type section, select AWS service

          3. In Use case section, for Service or use case, select Redshift.

          4. For Use case, select Redshift – Customizable.

          5. Click Next to advance to Add Permissions step.

          6. Click Next to skip Add Permissions step.

          7. Enter a Role name, for example, RedshiftProtegrity.

          8. Click Create role.

          9. After the role is created, click on the role. Record the following information:

            • Role Name (DBRoleName): ____________________
            • Role ARN (DBRoleARN): ____________________

          What’s Next

          3.3 - Protect Service Installation

          Install the protect service.

            Preparation

            1. Ensure that all the steps in Pre-Configuration are performed.

            2. Login to the AWS account console where Amazon Redshift Protector will be installed.

            3. Ensure that the required CloudFormation templates provided by Protegrity are available on your local computer.

            Create Protect Lambda IAM Execution Policy

            This task defines a policy used by the Protegrity Lambda function to write CloudWatch logs and access the KMS encryption key to decrypt the policy.

            Perform the following steps to create the Lambda execution role and required policies:

            1. From the AWS IAM console, select Policies > Create Policy.

            2. Select the JSON tab and copy the following sample policy.

              {
                "Version": "2012-10-17",
                "Statement": [
                  {
                    "Sid": "CloudWatchWriteLogs",
                    "Effect": "Allow",
                    "Action": [
                      "logs:CreateLogGroup",
                      "logs:CreateLogStream",
                      "logs:PutLogEvents"
                    ],
                    "Resource": "*"
                  },
                  {
                    "Sid": "KmsDecrypt",
                    "Effect": "Allow",
                    "Action": [
                      "kms:Decrypt"
                    ],
                    "Resource": [
                      "arn:aws:kms:*:*:key/*"
                    ]
                  }
                ]
              }
              
            3. For the KMS policy, replace the Resource with the ARN for the KMS key created in a previous step.

            4. Select Next, type in a policy name, for example, ProtegrityProtectLambdaPolicy and Create Policy. Record the policy name:

              ProtectLambdaPolicyName:__________________

            Create Protect Lambda IAM Role

            The following steps create the role to utilize the policy defined in Create Protect Lambda IAM Execution Policy.

            To create protect lambda IAM execution role:

            1. From the AWS IAM console, select Roles > Create Role.

            2. Select AWS Service > Lambda > Next.

            3. In the list, search and select the policy created in Create Protect Lambda IAM Execution Policy.

            4. Click Next

            5. Type the role name, for example, ProtegrityProtectRole

            6. Click Create role

            7. Record the role ARN.

              Role ARN (LambdaExecutionRoleArn): ___________________

            Install through CloudFormation

            The following steps describe the deployment of the Lambda function.

            To install through CloudFormation:

            1. Access CloudFormation and select the target AWS Region in the console.

            2. Click Create Stack and choose With new resources.

            3. Specify the template.

            4. Select Upload a template file.

            5. Upload the Protegrity-provided CloudFormation template called pty_protect_cf.json and click Next.

            6. Specify the stack details. Enter a stack name.

            7. Enter the required parameters. All the values were generated in the pre-configuration steps.

              Parameter

              Description

              DBRoleName

              Name of the account role created in the pre-configuration step

              ArtifactS3Bucket

              Name of S3 bucket created in the pre-configuration step

              LambdaExecutionRoleArn

              The ARN of Lambda role created in the prior step

              MinLogLevel

              Minimum log level for protect function. Allowed Values: off, severe, warning, info, config, all

              UsernameRegex

              If set, the effective policy user will be extracted from the user in the request.

            8. If you are not planning to deploy log forwarder you can skip this step. The log forwarder parameters can be provided later after log forwarder is deployed.

              Log Forwarder ParametersDescription
              KinesisLogStreamArnThe ARN of the AWS Kinesis stream where audit logs will be sent for aggregation
              AuditLogFlushIntervalTime interval in seconds used to accumulate audit logs before sending to Kinesis. Default value: 30. See Log Forwarder Performance section for more details.
            9. Proceed to the last step of the Create Stack wizard with defaults and click Submit to create CloudFormation stack.

            10. Select Outputs tab of the stack after stack is created.

            11. Record the following values:

              ProtectFunctionName: __________________________

              ProtectFunctionProductionAlias: __________________________

              ProtectLayerName: _____________________________

            Protect Lambda Configuration

            After CloudFormation stack is deployed, the Protect Lambda default configuration can be changed using Lambda environment configuration. See below for list of available configuration and instructions how to update it.

            • List of Protect Lambda Environment Variables

              Variable Name

              Description

              Notes

              LOG_REDSHIFT_CLUSTER_ARN

              When enabled, Redshift cluster ARN is recorded in CloudWatch audit log.

              Set LOG_REDSHIFT_CLUSTER_ARN = 1 to enable.

              See Audit Logging for audit log examples.

            • Updating Lambda Configuration

              From your AWS console, navigate to Lambda and select the following Lambda:

              Protegrity_Protect_<STACK_NAME>

              Select Configuration tab and scroll down to the Environment variables section. Select Edit then Add environment variable. For the list of allowed variables and corresponding values refer to the table above.

            Delete API Gateway (Optional)

            CloudFormation created an API Gateway that makes this product compatible with Snowflake. However, this service is not required for Amazon Redshift so it may be optionally removed.

            To delete API Gateway:

            1. From Services, access API Gateway.

            2. Select the API Gateway service that is created.

            3. Click Actions > Delete.

            Add Lambda Protect IAM Permissions to Role

            To add inline Lambda Protect IAM permissions to role:

            1. Select the role created in section Create IAM Account Role (DBRoleName).

            2. In the Permissions tab, click Add inline policy.

            3. Select the JSON tab and copy the following sample policy.

              {
                "Version": "2012-10-17",
                "Statement": [
                  {
                    "Sid": "ProtegrityProtectInvokePermission",
                    "Effect": "Allow",
                    "Action": "lambda:InvokeFunction",
                    "Resource": "arn:aws:lambda:*:*:function:*"
                  }
                ]
              }
              
            4. Edit the Resource value in the snippet with the ARN of the Protect Lambda function to further restrict privileges.

            Attach IAM Account Role to Redshift

            Perform the following steps to allow Redshift to invoke the Protect Lambda function.

            Attach the IAM role (DBRoleName) created in Create IAM Account Role to the Redshift cluster.

            To attach IAM account role to Redshift:

            1. From the AWS console, access Amazon Redshift and click on the cluster.

            2. Select Actions > Manage IAM Roles.

            3. Under Available IAM roles, select Enter ARN.

            4. Enter the Role ARN recorded in Create Protect Lambda IAM Role.

            5. Click Add IAM role.

            Test Connectivity

            Perform the following steps to verify if Redshift is working correctly with the Protegrity product.

            To test the connectivity:

            1. Access the Redshift SQL console.

            2. Copy and paste the following snippet into a worksheet.

              CREATE OR REPLACE EXTERNAL FUNCTION pty_unprotect_alpha(varchar) RETURNS varchar
              VOLATILE lambda '<replace_with_protect_function_name>:Production' iam_role 'arn:aws:iam::<you-awsaccount-
              number>:role/<role-name>
              
            3. Replace the placeholder values with the lambda function name and role created in earlier steps.

            4. Run the following command in the console:

              select pty_unprotect_alpha('UtfVk UHgcD!')
              
            5. Verify that the string hello world! is returned.

            Troubleshooting Tips

            Error

            Action

            Empty result or Invalid operation error

            1. If a permission exception occurred, please make sure the Redshift cluster was not in modification status when performing the step in the prior step. Try again.

            2. Try running the Lambda directly. Open the Lambda function and create the following test case.

              {
                "user": "test",
                "arguments": [
                  [
                    "UtfVk UHgcD!"
                  ]
                ],
                "query_id": 0,
                "external_function": "pty_unprotect_alpha"
              }
              
            3. If this step fails, please check the console for meaningful error. If the step succeeds, the installation is correct.

            4. Please recheck all the IAM configuration steps above.

            What’s Next

            3.4 - Policy Agent Installation

            Install the policy agent.

              The following sections will install the Policy Agent. The Policy Agent polls the ESA and deploys the policy to Protegrity Serverless as a static resource. Some of the installation steps are not required for the operation of the software but recommended for establishing a secure environment. Contact Protegrity Professional Services for further guidance on configuration alternatives in the Cloud.

              ESA Server

              Policy Agent Lambda requires ESA server running and accessible on TCP port 443.

              Note down ESA IP address:

              ESA IP Address (EsaIpAddress): ___________________

              Certificates on ESA

              Whether your ESA is configured with default self-signed certificate or your corporate CA certificate, Policy Agent can validate authenticity of ESA connection using CA certificate. The process for both scenarios is the same:

              • Obtain CA certificate
              • Convert CA certificate to a value accepted by Policy Agent
              • Provide converted CA certificate value to Policy Agent

              To obtain self-signed CA certificate from ESA:

              1. Log in to ESA Web UI.

              2. Select Settings > Network > Manage Certificates.

              3. Hover over Server Certificate and click on download icon to download the CA certificate.

              4. To convert downloaded CA certificate to a value accepted by Policy Agent, open the downloaded PEM file in text editor and replace all new lines with escaped new line: \n.

                To escape new lines from command line, use one of the following commands depending on your operating system:

                Linux Bash:

                awk 'NF {printf "%s\\n",$0;}' ProtegrityCA.pem > output.txt
                

                Windows PowerShell:

                (Get-Content '.\ProtegrityCA.pem') -join '\n' | Set-Content 'output.txt'
                
              5. Record the certificate content with new lines escaped.

                ESA CA Server Certificate (EsaCaCert): ___________________

                This value will be used to set PTY_ESA_CA_SERVER_CERT or PTY_ESA_CA_SERVER_CERT_SECRET Lambda variable in section Policy Agent Lambda Configuration

              For more information about ESA certificate management refer to Certificate Management Guide in ESA documentation.

              Identify or Create a new VPC

              Establish a VPC where the Policy Agent will be hosted. This VPC will need connectivity to the ESA. The VPC should be in the same account and region established in Pre-Configuration.

              VPC name: ___________________

              VPC Subnet Configuration

              Identify or create a new subnet in the VPC where tha Lambda function will be connected to. It is recommended to use a private subnet.

              Subnet name: ___________________

              NAT Gateway For ESA Hosted Outside AWS Network

              If ESA server is hosted outside of the AWS Cloud network, the VPC configured for Lambda function must ensure additional network configuration is available to allow connectivity with ESA. For instance if ESA has a public IP, the Lambda function VPC must have public subnet with a NAT server to allow routing traffic outside of the AWS network. A Routing Table and Network ACL may need to be configured for outbound access to the ESA as well.

              VPC Endpoints Configuration

              If an internal VPC was created, then add VPC Endpoints, which will be used by the Policy Agent to access AWS services. Policy Agent needs access to the following AWS services:

              Type

              Service name

              Interface

              com.amazonaws.{REGION}.secretsmanager

              Interface

              com.amazonaws.{REGION}.kms

              Gateway

              com.amazonaws.{REGION}.s3

              Interface

              com.amazonaws.{REGION}.lambda

              Identify or Create Security Groups

              Policy Agent and cloud-based ESA appliance use AWS security groups to control traffic that is allowed to leave and reach them. Policy Agent runs on schedule and is mostly concerned with allowing traffic out of itself to ESA and AWS services it depends on. ESA runs most of the time and it must allow Policy Agent to connect to it.

              Policy Agent security group must allow outbound traffic using rules described in the table below. To edit security group navigate:

              From VPC > Security Groups > Policy Agent Security Group configuration.

              TypeProtocolPort RangeDestinationReason
              Custom TCPTCP443Policy Agent Lambda SGESA Communication
              HTTPSTCP443AnyAWS Services

              Record Policy Agent security group ID:

              Policy Agent Security Group Id: ___________________

              Policy Agent will reach out to ESA on port 443. Create following inbound security group rule for cloud-based ESA appliance to allow connections from Policy Agent:

              TypeProtocolPort RangeSource
              Custom TCPTCP443Policy Agent Lambda SG

              Creating ESA Credentials

              Policy Agent Lambda requires ESA credentials to be provided as one of the three options.

              Option 1: Secrets Manager

              Creating secrets manager secret with ESA username and password.

              1. From the AWS Secrets Manager Console, select Store New Secret.

              2. Select Other Type of Secrets.

              3. Specify the username and password key value pair.

              4. Select the encryption key or leave default AWS managed key.

              5. Specify the Secret Name and record it.

                ESA Credentials Secret Name: __________________

              Option 2: KMS Encrypted Password

              ESA password is encrypted with AWS KMS symmetric key.

              1. Create AWS KMS symmetric key which will be used to encrypt ESA password. See Create KMS Key for instructions on how to create KMS symmetric key using AWS console.

              2. Record KMS Key ARN.

                ESA PASSWORD KMS KEY ARN: __________________

              3. Run AWS CLI command to encrypt ESA password. Below you can find sample Linux aws cli command. Replace <key_arn> with KMS symmetric key ARN.

                aws kms encrypt --key-id <key_arn> --plaintext $(echo '<esa_password>' | base64 )
                
              4. Sample output.

                {
                  "CiphertextBlob": "esa_encrypted_password",
                  "KeyId": "arn:aws:kms:region:aws_account:key/key_id ",
                  "EncryptionAlgorithm": "SYMMETRIC_DEFAULT"
                }
                
              5. Record ESA username and encrypted password.

                ESA USERNAME: __________________

                ESA ENCRYPTED PASSWORD: __________________

              Option 3: Custom AWS Lambda function

              With this option ESA username and password are returned by a custom AWS Lambda function. This method may be used to get the username and password from external vaults.

              1. Create AWS Lambda in any AWS supported runtime.

                1. There is no input needed.

                2. The Lambda function must return the following response schema.

                  response:
                  type: object
                    properties:
                      username: string
                      password: string
                  

                  For example,

                  example output: {"username": "admin", "password": "Password1234"}
                  
                3. Sample AWS Lambda function in Python:

                  import json
                  
                  def lambda_handler(event, context):
                  
                      return {"username": "admin", "password": "password1234"}
                  
              2. Record the Lambda name:

                Custom AWS lambda for ESA credentials: _______________

              Create Agent Lambda IAM Policy

              Follow the steps below to create Lambda execution policies.

              Create Agent Lambda IAM policy

              1. From AWS IAM console, select Policies > Create Policy.

              2. Select JSON tab and copy the following snippet.

                {
                  "Version": "2012-10-17",
                  "Statement": [
                    {
                      "Sid": "EC2ModifyNetworkInterfaces",
                      "Effect": "Allow",
                      "Action": [
                        "ec2:CreateNetworkInterface",
                        "ec2:DescribeNetworkInterfaces",
                        "ec2:DeleteNetworkInterface"
                      ],
                      "Resource": "*"
                    },
                    {
                      "Sid": "CloudWatchWriteLogs",
                      "Effect": "Allow",
                      "Action": [
                        "logs:CreateLogGroup",
                        "logs:CreateLogStream",
                        "logs:PutLogEvents"
                      ],
                      "Resource": "*"
                    },
                    {
                      "Sid": "LambdaUpdateFunction",
                      "Effect": "Allow",
                      "Action": [
                        "lambda:UpdateFunctionConfiguration"
                      ],
                      "Resource": [
                        "arn:aws:lambda:*:*:function:*"
                      ]
                    },
                    {
                      "Sid": "LambdaReadLayerVersion",
                      "Effect": "Allow",
                      "Action": [
                        "lambda:GetLayerVersion",
                        "lambda:ListLayerVersions"
                      ],
                      "Resource": "*"
                    },
                    {
                      "Sid": "LambdaDeleteLayerVersion",
                      "Effect": "Allow",
                      "Action": "lambda:DeleteLayerVersion",
                      "Resource": "arn:aws:lambda:*:*:layer:*:*"
                    },
                    {
                      "Sid": "LambdaPublishLayerVersion",
                      "Effect": "Allow",
                      "Action": "lambda:PublishLayerVersion",
                      "Resource": "arn:aws:lambda:*:*:layer:*"
                    },
                    {
                      "Sid": "S3GetObject",
                      "Effect": "Allow",
                      "Action": [
                        "s3:GetObject"
                      ],
                      "Resource": "arn:aws:s3:::*/*"
                    },
                    {
                      "Sid": "S3PutObject",
                      "Effect": "Allow",
                      "Action": [
                        "s3:PutObject"
                      ],
                      "Resource": "arn:aws:s3:::*/*"
                    },
                    {
                      "Sid": "KmsEncrypt",
                      "Effect": "Allow",
                      "Action": [
                        "kms:GetPublicKey"
                      ],
                      "Resource": [
                        "arn:aws:kms:*:*:key/*"
                      ]
                    },
                    {
                      "Sid": "SecretsManagerGetSecret",
                      "Effect": "Allow",
                      "Action": [
                        "secretsmanager:GetSecretValue"
                      ],
                      "Resource": [
                        "arn:aws:secretsmanager:*:*:secret:*"
                      ]
                    },
                    {
                      "Sid": "LambdaGetConfiguration",
                      "Effect": "Allow",
                      "Action": [
                          "lambda:GetFunctionConfiguration"
                      ],
                      "Resource": [
                          "arn:aws:lambda:*:*:function:*"
                      ]
                    }
                  ]
                }
                
              3. Replace wildcard * with the region, account, and resource name information where required.

              4. This step is required if KMS is used to encrypt ESA password.

                Add policy entry below. Replace ESA PASSWORD KMS KEY ARN with the value recorded in Option 2: KMS Encrypted Password.

                
                  {
                    "Sid": "KmsDecryptEsaPassword",
                    "Effect": "Allow",
                    "Action": [
                      "kms:Decrypt"
                    ],
                    "Resource": [
                      "**ESA PASSWORD KMS KEY ARN**"
                    ]
                  }
                
              5. Select Next type in the policy name and Create Policy. Record policy name:

                Policy Name: ___________________

              Create Agent Lambda IAM Role

              Perform the following steps to create Agent Lambda execution IAM role.

              To create agent Lambda IAM role:

              1. From AWS IAM console, select Roles > Create Role.

              2. Select AWS Service > Lambda > Next.

              3. Select the policy created in Create Agent Lambda IAM policy.

              4. Proceed to Name, Review and Create.

              5. Type the role name, for example, ProtegrityAgentRole and click Confirm.

              6. Select Create role.

              7. Record the role ARN.

                Agent Lambda IAM Execution Role Name: ___________________

              Corporate Firewall Configuration

              If an on-premise firewall is used, then the firewall must allow access from the NAT Gateway to an ESA. The firewall must allow access from the NAT Gateway IP to ESA via port 443 and 443.

              CloudFormation Installation

              Create the Policy Agent in the VPC using the CloudFormation script provided by Protegrity.

              1. Access the CloudFormation service.

              2. Select the target installation region.

              3. Create a stack with new resources.

              4. Upload the Policy Agent CloudFormation template (file name: pty_agent_cf.json).

              5. Specify the following parameters for Cloud Formation:

                ParameterDescriptionNote
                VPCVPC where the Policy Agent will be hostedIdentify or Create a new VPC
                SubnetSubnet where the Policy Agent will be hostedVPC Subnet Configuration
                PolicyAgentSecurityGroupIdSecurity Group Id, which allows communication between the Policy Agent and the ESAIdentify or Create Security Groups
                LambdaExecutionRoleArnAgent Lambda IAM execution role ARN allowing access to the S3 bucket, KMS encryption Key, Lambda and Lambda LayerCreate Agent Lambda IAM Role
                ArtifactS3BucketS3 bucket name with deployment package for the Policy AgentUse S3 Bucket name recorded in Create S3 bucket for Installing Artifacts
                CreateCRONJobSet to True to create a CloudWatch schedule for the agent to run.Default: False

              Policy Agent Lambda Configuration

              After the CloudFormation stack is deployed, the Policy Agent Lambda must be configured with parameters recorded in earlier steps. From your AWS Console, navigate to lambda and select the following Lambda.

              Protegrity_Agent<STACK_NAME>_

              Select Configuration tab and scroll down to the Environment variables section. Select Editand replace all entries with the actual values.

              Parameter

              Description

              Notes

              PTY_ESA_IP

              ESA IP address or hostname

              ESA Server

              PTY_ESA_CA_SERVER_CERT

              ESA self-signed CA certificate or your corporate CA certificate used by policy Agent Lambda to ensure ESA is the trusted server.

              Recorded in step Certificates on ESA

              In case ESA is configured with publicly signed certificates, the PTY_ESA_CA_SERVER_CERT configuration will be ignored.

              PTY_ESA_CA_SERVER_CERT_SECRET

              This configuration option fulfills the same function as PTY_ESA_CA_SERVER_CERT but supports larger configuration values, making it the recommended choice. The value should specify the name of the AWS Secrets Manager secret containing the ESA self-signed CA certificate. The secret value should be set to the json with “PTY_ESA_CA_SERVER_CERT” key and PEM formated CA certificate content value as shown below.

              {
                "PTY_ESA_CA_SERVER_CERT":"-----BEGIN CERTIFICATE----- MIIF..."
              }
              

              Recorded in step Certificates on ESA

              In case ESA is configured with publicly signed certificates, the PTY_ESA_CA_SERVER_CERT_SECRET configuration will be ignored. When both PTY_ESA_CA_SERVER_CERT and PTY_ESA_CA_SERVER_CERT_SECRET are configured the PTY_ESA_CA_SERVER_CERT_SECRET takes precedence.

              PTY_ESA_CREDENTIALS_SECRET

              ESA username and password (encrypted value by AWS Secrets Manager)

              Option 1: Secrets Manager

              PTY_DATASTORE_KEY

              ESA policy datastore public key fingerprint (64 char long) e.g. 123bff642f621123d845f006c6bfff27737b21299e8a2ef6380aa642e76e89e5.

              The export key is the public part of an asymmetric key pair created in a Create KMS Key. A user with Security Officer permissions adds the public key to the data store in ESA via Policy Management > Data Stores > Export Keys. The fingerprint can then be copied using the Copy Fingerprint icon next to the key. Refer to Exporting Keys to Datastore for details.

              AWS_KMS_KEY_ID

              KMS key id or full ARN e.g. arn:aws:kms:us-west-2:112233445566:key/bfb6c4fb-509a-43ac-b0aa-82f1ca0b52d3

              Create KMS Key

              AWS_POLICY_S3_BUCKET

              S3 bucket where the encrypted policy will be written

              S3 bucket of your choice

              AWS_POLICY_S3_FILENAME

              Filename of the encrypted policy stored in S3 bucket

              Default: protegrity-policy.zip

              AWS_PROTECT_FN_NAME

              Comma separated list of Protect function names or ARNs

              ProtectFunctionName(s), recorded in CloudFormation Installation

              DISABLE_DEPLOY

              This flag can be either 1 or 0. If set to 1, then the agent will not update PTY_PROTECT lambda with the newest policy. Else, the policy will be saved in the S3 bucket and deployed to the Lambda Layer

              Default: 0

              AWS_POLICY_LAYER_NAME

              Lambda layer used to store the Protegrity policy used by the PTY_PROTECT function

               

              POLICY_LAYER_RETAIN

              Number of policy versions to retain as backup. (e.g. 2 will retain the latest 2 policies and remove older ones). -1 retains all.

              Default: 2

              POLICY_PULL_TIMEOUT

              Time in seconds to wait for the ESA to send the full policy

              Default: 20s

              ESA_CONNECTION_TIMEOUT

              Time in seconds to wait for the ESA response

              Default: 5s

              LOG_LEVEL

              Application and audit logs verbiage level

              Default: INFO

              Allowed values: DEBUG – the most verbose, INFO, WARNING, ERROR – the least verbose

              PTY_CORE_EMPTYSTRING

              Override default behavior. Empty string response values are returned as null values. For instance:

              (un)protect(’’) -> null

              (un)protect(’’) -> ''

              Default: empty

              Allowed values:

              null

              empty

              PTY_CORE_CASESENSITIVE

              Specifies whether policy usernames should be case sensitive

              Default: no

              Allowed values:

              yes

              no

              PTY_ADDIPADDRESSHEADER

              When enabled, agent will send its source IP address in the request header. This configuration works in conjunction with ESA hubcontroller configuration ASSIGN_DATASTORE_USING_NODE_IP (default=false). See Associating ESA Data Store With Cloud Protect Agent for more information.

              Default: yes

              Allowed values:

              yes

              no

              PTY_ESA_USERNAME

              Plaintext ESA username which is used together with PTY_ESA_ENCRYPTED_PASSWORD as an optional ESA credentials

              Option 2: KMS Encrypted Password

              Presence of this parameter will cause PTY_ESA_CREDENTIALS_SECRET to be ignored

              PTY_ESA_ENCRYPTED_PASSWORD

              ESA password encrypted with KMS symmetric key.

              Example AWS cli command to generate the value:

              aws kms encrypt --key-id <your key ARN> --plaintext '<your-esa-password-base64>'

              Option 2: KMS Encrypted Password

              Presence of this parameter will cause PTY_ESA_CREDENTIALS_SECRET to be ignored

              Value must be base64 encoded

              EMPTY_POLICY_S3

              This flag can be either 1 or 0. If set to 1, then the agent will remove the content of the policy file in S3 bucket, but will keep the checksum in the metadata. Else, the policy will be saved in the S3 bucket and not removed.

              Default: 0

              PTY_ESA_CREDENTIALS_LAMBDA

              Lambda function to return ESA credentials

              Recorded in step Option 3: Custom AWS Lambda function LAMBDA FOR ESA CREDENTIALS. Presence of PTY_ESA_USERNAME, or PTY_ESA_CREDENTIALS_SECRET will cause this value to be ignored.

              The Policy Agent Lambda must have network access and IAM permissions to invoke the custom ESA Credentials Lambda you have created in Option 3: Custom AWS Lambda function.

              Test Installation

              Open the Lambda and configure Test to execute the lambda and specify the default test event. Wait for around 20 seconds for the Lambda to complete. If policy is downloaded successfully, then a success message appears.

              Navigate to the AWS_POLICY_S3_BUCKET bucket and verify that the AWS_POLICY_S3_FILENAME file was created.

              Troubleshooting

              Lambda Error

              Example Error

              Action

              Task timed out after x seconds

              2020-10-06T23:40:54.121Z 2dc84942-b5cc-4be9-aa4c-965f322307e4 Task timed out after 90.09 seconds
              
              1. Ensure that there is network connectivity between the Lambda and ESA. Check the Security groups and/or Network firewall configuration
              2. When using internal VPC, AWS Lambda needs to have access to AWS Network. The Policy Agent Lambda can start using Secrets Manager with Amazon VPC endpoints by creating an Amazon VPC endpoint for Secrets Manager.

              ESA connection error. Failed to download certificates

              Policy Pull takes a long time

              {
                "errorMessage": "Timeout! Unable to download policy in 20 seconds.",
                "errorType": "Exception",
                "stackTrace": [...]
              }
              
              1. Increase POLICY_PULL_TIMEOUT.
              2. Ensure that there is at least 1 policy with datastore matching the Lambda Policy Agent. Other considerations:
                1. Policy has default datastore.
                2. Policy has datastores matching AWS lambda IP range (check the subnet IP Range).
                3. Lambda function has static IP, and at least one Data store has matching IP.

              ESA connection error. Failed to download certificates. HTTP response code: 401

              {
                "errorMessage": "ESA connection error. Failed to download certificates. HTTP response code: 401.",
                "errorType": "ConnectionError",
                "stackTrace": [...]
              }
              

              Ensure that the PTY_ESA_CREDENTIALS_SECRET has correct ESA username and password

              An error occurred (AccessDeniedException) when calling xyz operation

              xyz Access Denied: Exception
              Traceback (most recent call last):
                … Exception: xyz Access Denied
              

              Ensure that the Lambda execution role has permission to call the xyz operation

              Access Denied to Secret Manager.

              Secrets Manager Access Denied: Exception
              Traceback (most recent call last):
                … Exception: Secrets Manager Access Denied
              
              1. Ensure that the Lambda execution role has permissions to get the Secret Manager secret name.
              2. Ensure that the Lambda execution role has permission to get the Secret Manager secret Encryption Key.

              Master Key xyz unable to generate data key

              Ensure that the Lambda can access xyz CMK key

              The S3 bucket server-side encryption is enabled, the encryption key type is SSE-KMS but the Policy Agent execution IAM role doesn’t have permissions to encrypt using the KMS key .

              [ERROR] PolicyAgentException: An error occurred (AccessDenied) when calling the PutObject operation: Access Denied
              

              Add the following permissions to the Policy Agent excution role.

              kms:Decrypt
              kms:GenerateDatakey
              

              The S3 bucket has bucket policy to only allow access from within the VPC.

              An error occurred (AccessDeniedException) when calling the PublishLayerVersion operation: Your access has been denied by S3,
              please make sure your request credentials have permission to GetObject for BUCKET_NAME/FILENAME. S3 Error Code: AccessDenied. S3 Error Message: Access Denied
              

              The Policy Agent publishes a new Lambda Layer version, and the Lambda Layer service uploads the policy file from the s3 bucket and the upload request is originated from the AWS service outside the Policy Agent Lambda VPC. Update the S3 bucket resource policy to allow access from AWS Service. Sample security policy to lock down access to the vpc:

              {
                "Version": "2012-10-17",
                "Statement": [
                  {
                    "Sid": "VpcRestrictions",
                    "Effect": "Deny",
                    "Principal": {
                      "AWS": "*"
                    },
                    "Action": "s3:*Object",
                    "Resource": [
                      "arn:aws:s3:::<s3_bucket_name>/*",
                      "arn:aws:s3:::<s3_bucket_name>"
                    ],
                    "Condition": {
                      "Bool": {
                        "aws:ViaAWSService": "false"
                      },
                      "StringNotEquals": {
                        "aws:sourceVpc": "<vpc_id>"
                      }
                    }
                  }
                ]
              }
              

              Additional Configuration

              Strengthen the KMS IAM policy by granting access only to the required Lambda function(s).

              Finalize the IAM policy for the Lambda Execution Role. Ensure to replace wildcard * with the region, account, and resource name information where required.

              For example,

              "arn:aws:lambda:*:*:function:*" -> "arn:aws:lambda:us-east-1:account:function:function_name"
              

              Policy Agent Schedule

              If specified in CloudFormation Installation, the agent installation created a CloudWatch event rule, which checks for policy update on an hourly schedule. This schedule can be altered to the required frequency.

              Under CloudWatch > Events > Rules, find Protegrity_Agent_{stack_name}. Click Action > Edit Set the cron expression. A cron expression can easily be defined using CronMaker, a free online tool. Refer to http://www.cronmaker.com.

              What’s Next

              3.5 - Audit Log Forwarder Installation

              Install the audit log forwarder.

                The following sections show steps how to install Audit Log Forwarder component in the AWS Cloud. The Log Forwarder deployment allows for the audit logs generated by Protector to be delivered to ESA for auditing and governance purposes. Log Forwarder component is optional and is not required for the Protector Service to work properly. See Log Forwarding Architecture section in this document for more information. Some of the installation steps are not required for the operation of the software but recommended for establishing a secure environment. C ontact Protegrity for further guidance on configuration alternatives in the Cloud.

                ESA Audit Store Configuration

                ESA server is required as the recipient of audit logs. Verify the information below to ensure ESA is accessible and configured properly.

                1. ESA server running and accessible on TCP port 9200 (Audit Store) or 24284 (td-agent).

                2. Audit Store service is configured and running on ESA. Applies when audit logs are output to Audit Store directly or through td-agent. For information related to ESA Audit Store configuration, refer to Audit Store Guide.

                3. (Optional) td-agent is configured for external input. For more information related to td-agent configuration, refer to ESA guide Sending logs to an external security information and event management (SIEM).

                Certificates on ESA

                By default, ESA is configured with self-signed certificates, which can optionally be validated using a self-signed CA certificate supplied in the Log Forwarder configuration. If no CA certificate is provided, the Log Forwarder will skip server certificate validation.

                If ESA is configured with publicly signed certificates, this section can be skipped since the forwarder Lambda will use the public CA to validate ESA certificates.

                To obtain the self-signed CA certificate from ESA:

                1. Download ESA CA certificate from the /etc/ksa/certificates/plug directory of the ESA

                2. After certificate is downloaded, open the PEM file in text editor and replace all new lines with escaped new line: \n.

                  To escape new lines from command line, use one of the following commands depending on your operating system:

                  Linux Bash:

                  awk 'NF {printf "%s\\n",$0;}' ProtegrityCA.pem > output.txt
                  

                  Windows PowerShell:

                  (Get-Content '.\ProtegrityCA.pem') -join '\n' | Set-Content 'output.txt'
                  
                3. Record the certificate content with new lines escaped.

                  ESA CA Server Certificate (EsaCaCert): ___________________

                  This value will be used to set PtyEsaCaServerCert cloudformation parameter in section Install through CloudFormation

                For more information about ESA certificate management refer to Certificate Management Guide in ESA documentation.

                AWS VPC Configuration

                Log forwarder Lambda function requires network connectivity to ESA, similar to Policy Agent Lambda function. Therefore, it can be hosted in the same VPC as Policy Agent.

                Separate VPC can be used, as long as it provides network connectivity to ESA.

                VPC Name: ___________________

                VPC Subnet Configuration

                Log Forwarder can be connected to the same subnet as Policy Agent or separate one as long as it provides connectivity to ESA.

                Subnet Name: ___________________

                NAT Gateway For ESA Hosted Outside AWS Network

                If ESA server is hosted outside of the AWS Cloud network, the VPC configured for Lambda function must ensure additional network configuration is available to allow connectivity with ESA. For instance if ESA has a public IP, the Lambda function VPC must have public subnet with a NAT server to allow routing traffic outside of the AWS network. A Routing Table and Network ACL may need to be configured for outbound access to the ESA as well.

                VPC Endpoint Configuration

                Log Forwarder Lambda function requires connectivity to Secrets Manager AWS service. If the VPC identified in the steps before has no connectivity to public internet through the NAT Gateway, then the following service endpoint must be configured:

                • com.amazonaws.{REGION}.cloudwatch
                • com.amazonaws.{REGION}.secretsmanager
                • com.amazonaws.{REGION}.kms

                Security Group Configuration

                Security groups restrict communication between Log Forwarder Lambda function and the ESA appliance. The following rules must be in place for ESA and Log Forwarder Lambda function.

                From VPC > Security Groups > Log Forwarder Security Group configuration.

                TypeProtocolPort RangeDestinationReason
                Custom TCPTCP9200Log Forwarder Lambda SGESA Communication

                Record the name of Log Forwarder security group name.

                Log Forwarder Security Group Id: ___________________

                The following port must be open for the ESA. If the ESA is running in the Cloud, then create the following security.

                ESA Security Group configuration

                TypeProtocolPort RangeSource
                Custom TCPTCP9200Log Forwarder Lambda SG

                Configure ESA Audit Store Credentials

                Audit Log Forwarder can optionally authenticate with ESA using certificate-based authentication with a client certificate and certificate key. If used, both the certificate and certificate key will be stored in AWS Secrets Manager.

                Download the following certificates from the /etc/ksa/certificates/plug directory of the ESA:

                • client.key
                • client.pem

                After certificates are downloaded, open each PEM file in text editor and replace all new lines with escaped new line: \n. To escape new lines from command line, use one of the commands below depending on your operating system.

                Linux Bash:

                awk 'NF {printf "%s\\n",$0;}' client.key > private_key.txt
                awk 'NF {printf "%s\\n",$0;}' client.pem > public_key.txt
                

                Windows PowerShell:

                (Get-Content '.\client.key') -join '\n' | Set-Content 'private_key.pem'
                (Get-Content '.\client.pem') -join '\n' | Set-Content 'public_key.pem'
                

                For more information on how to configure client certificate authentication for Audit Store on ESA refer to Audit Store Guide.

                To create secret with ESA client certificate/key pair in AWS Secrets Manager.

                1. From the AWS Secrets Manager Console, select Store New Secret.

                2. Select Other Type of Secrets.

                3. Specify the private_key and public_key value pair.

                4. Select the encryption key or leave default AWS managed key.

                5. Specify the Secret Name and record it below.

                  ESA Client Certificate/Key Pair Secret Name: ___________________

                  This value will be used to set PtyEsaClientCertificatesSecretId cloudformation parameter in section Install through CloudFormation

                Create Audit Log Forwarder IAM Execution Policy

                This task defines a policy used by the Protegrity Log Forwarder Lambda function to write CloudWatch logs, access the KMS encryption key to decrypt the policy and access Secrets Manager for log forwarder user credentials.

                Perform the following steps to create the Lambda execution role and required policies:

                1. From the AWS IAM console, select Policies > Create Policy.

                2. Select the JSON tab and copy the following sample policy.

                  {
                    "Version": "2012-10-17",
                    "Statement": [
                      {
                        "Sid": "EC2ModifyNetworkInterfaces",
                        "Effect": "Allow",
                        "Action": [
                          "ec2:CreateNetworkInterface",
                          "ec2:DescribeNetworkInterfaces",
                          "ec2:DeleteNetworkInterface"
                        ],
                        "Resource": "*"
                      },
                      {
                        "Sid": "CloudWatchWriteLogs",
                        "Effect": "Allow",
                        "Action": [
                          "logs:CreateLogGroup",
                          "logs:CreateLogStream",
                          "logs:PutLogEvents"
                        ],
                        "Resource": "*"
                      },
                      {
                        "Sid": "KmsDecrypt",
                        "Effect": "Allow",
                        "Action": [
                          "kms:Decrypt"
                        ],
                        "Resource": [
                          "arn:aws:kms:*:*:key/*"
                        ]
                      },
                      {
                          "Sid": "KinesisStreamRead",
                          "Effect": "Allow",
                          "Action": [
                              "kinesis:GetRecords",
                              "kinesis:GetShardIterator",
                              "kinesis:DescribeStream",
                              "kinesis:DescribeStreamSummary",
                              "kinesis:ListShards",
                              "kinesis:ListStreams"
                          ],
                          "Resource": "*"
                      },
                      {
                        "Sid": "SecretsManagerGetSecret",
                        "Effect": "Allow",
                        "Action": [
                          "secretsmanager:GetSecretValue"
                        ],
                        "Resource": [
                          "arn:aws:secretsmanager:*:*:secret:*"
                        ]
                      }
                    ]
                  }
                  
                3. For the KMS policy, replace the Resource with the ARN for the KMS key created in a previous step.

                4. Select Review policy, type in a policy name, for example, ProtegrityLogForwarderLambdaPolicy and Confirm. Record the policy name:

                  LogForwarderLambdaPolicyName:__________________

                Create Log Forwarder IAM Role

                Perform the following steps to create Log Forwarder execution IAM role.

                To create Log Forwarder IAM role:

                1. From AWS IAM console, select Roles > Create Role.

                2. Select AWS Service > Lambda > Next.

                3. Select the policy created in Create Audit Log Forwarder IAM Execution Policy.

                4. Proceed to Name, Review and Create.

                5. Type the role name, for example, ProtegrityForwarderRole and click Confirm.

                6. Record the role ARN.

                  Log Forwarder IAM Execution Role Name: ___________________

                Installation Artifacts

                Audit Log Forwarder installation artifacts are part of the same deployment package as the one used for protect and policy agent services. Follow the steps below to ensure the right artifacts are available for log forwarder installation.

                1. Verify that the Protegrity deployment package is available on your local system, if not, you can download it from the Protegrity portal.

                2. Extract the pty_log_forwarder_cf.json cloud formation file from the deployment package.

                3. Check the S3 deployment bucket identified in section Create S3 bucket for Installing Artifacts. Make sure that all Protegrity deployment zip files are uploaded to the S3 bucket.

                Install through CloudFormation

                The following steps describe the deployment of the Audit Log Forwarder AWS cloud components.

                1. Access CloudFormation and select the target AWS Region in the console.

                2. Click Create Stack and choose With new resources.

                3. Specify the template.

                4. Select Upload a template file.

                5. Upload the Protegrity-provided CloudFormation template called pty_log_forwarder_cf.json and click Next.

                6. Specify the stack details. Enter a stack name.

                7. Enter the required parameters. All the values were generated in the pre-configuration steps.

                Parameter

                Description

                Default Value

                Required

                LogForwarderSubnets

                Subnets where the Log Forwarder will be hosted.

                 

                 

                LogForwarderSecurityGroups

                Security Groups, which allow communication between the Log Forwarder and ESA.

                 

                X

                LambdaExecutionRoleArn

                The ARN of Lambda role created in the prior step.

                 

                X

                ArtifactS3Bucket

                Name of S3 bucket created in the pre-configuration step.

                 

                X

                LogDestinationEsaIp

                IP or FQDN of the ESA instance or cluster.

                 

                X

                AuditLogOutput

                Audit log processor to target on ESA. Allowed values: audit-store, td-agent

                audit-store

                X

                PtyEsaClientCertificatesSecretId

                AWS Secrets Manager secret id containing client certificates used for authentication with ESA Audit Store. It is expected that the public key will be stored in a field public_key and the private key in a field named private_key.

                This parameter is optional. If not provided, Log Forwarder will connect to ESA without client certificate authentication.

                EsaTlsDisableCertVerify

                Disable certificate verification when connecting to ESA if set to 1. This is only for dev purposes, do not disable in production environment.

                0

                X

                PtyEsaCaServerCert

                ESA self-signed CA certificate used by log forwarder Lambda to ensure ESA is the trusted server.

                Recorded in step Certificates on ESA

                In case ESA is configured with publicly signed certificates, the PtyEsaCaServerCert configuration will be ignored.

                 

                EsaConnectTimeout

                Time in seconds to wait for the ESA response. Minimum value: 1.

                5

                X

                EsaVirtualHost

                ESA virtual hostname. This configuration is optional and it can be used when proxy server is present and supports TLS SNI extension.

                 

                 

                KinesisLogStreamRetentionPeriodHours

                The number of hours for the log records to be stored in Kinesis Stream in case log destination server is not available. Minimum value: 24. See Log Forwarder Performance section for more details.

                24

                X

                KinesisLogStreamShardCount

                The number of shards that the Kinesis log stream uses. For greater provisioned throughput, increase the number of shards. Minimum value: 1. See Log Forwarder Performance section for more details.

                10

                X

                MinLogLevel

                Minimum log level for protect function. Allowed Values: off, severe, warning, info, config, all

                severe

                X

                1. Click Next with defaults to complete CloudFormation.

                2. After CloudFormation is completed, select the Outputstab in the stack.

                3. Record the following values

                  KinesisLogStreamArn: ________________________________

                Add Kinesis Put Record permission to the Protect Function IAM Role

                1. Login to the AWS account that hosts the Protect Lambda Function.

                2. Search for Protect Lambda Function IAM Execution Role Name created in Create Protect Lambda IAM role.

                3. Under Permissions policies, select Add Permissions > Create inline policy.

                4. In Specify permissions view, switch to JSON.

                5. Copy the policy json from below replacing the placeholder value indicated in the following snippet as <Audit Log Kinesis Stream ARN> with the value recorded in the previous step.

                  {
                  	"Version": "2012-10-17",
                  	"Statement": [
                  		{
                  			"Sid": "KinesisPutRecords",
                  			"Effect": "Allow",
                  			"Action": "kinesis:PutRecords",
                  			"Resource": "<Audit Log Kinesis Stream ARN>"
                  		}
                  	]
                  }
                  
                6. When you are finished, choose Next.

                7. On the Review and create page, type a Name, then choose Create policy.

                Test Log Forwarder Installation

                Testing in this section validates the connectivity between Log Forwarder and ESA. The sample policy included with the initial installation and test event below are not based on your ESA policy. Any logs forwarded to ESA which are not signed with a policy generated by your ESA will not be added to the audit store.

                Install Log Forwarder and configure according to previous sections. Log Forwarder configuration MinLogLevel must be at least info level.

                1. Navigate to the log forwarder lambda function.

                2. Select the Test tab.

                3. Copy the json test event into the Event JSON pane.

                  {
                      "Records": [
                          {
                              "kinesis": {
                                  "kinesisSchemaVersion": "1.0",
                                  "partitionKey": "041e96d78c778677ce43f50076a8ae3e",
                                  "sequenceNumber": "49620336010289430959432297775520367512250709822916263938",
                                  "data": "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",
                                  "approximateArrivalTimestamp": 1626878559.213
                              },
                              "eventSource": "aws:kinesis",
                              "eventVersion": "1.0",
                              "eventID": "shardId-000000000000:49620336010289430959432297775520367512250709822916261234",
                              "eventName": "aws:kinesis:record",
                              "invokeIdentityArn": "arn:aws:iam::555555555555:role/service-role/TestRole",
                              "awsRegion": "us-east-1",
                              "eventSourceARN": "arn:aws:kinesis:us-east-1:555555555555:stream/CloudProtectEventStream"
                          }
                      ]
                  }
                  
                4. Select Test to execute the test event.

                5. Test is successful if the Log Output of test results contains the following log:

                  [INFO] [kinesis-log-aggregation-format.cpp:77] Aggregated 1 records into 0 aggregated, 1 forwarded and 0 failed records
                  

                  If the log is not present, please consult the Troubleshooting section for common errors and solutions.

                Update Protector With Kinesis Log Stream

                In this section, Kinesis log stream ARN will be provided to the Protect Function installation.

                1. Navigate to the Protector CloudFormation stack created in the protector installation section.

                2. Select Update.

                3. Choose Use existing template > Next.

                4. Set parameter KinesisLogStreamArn to the output value recorded in Install through CloudFormation.

                5. Proceed with Next and Submit the changes.

                6. Continue to the next section once stack status indicates UPDATE_COMPLETE.

                Update Policy Agent With Log Forwarder Function Target

                Log Forwarder Lambda function requires a policy layer which is in sync with the Protegrity Protector. This section will describe the steps to update the policy agent to include updating Log Forwarder Lambda function.

                1. Navigate to the Policy Agent Function created in Policy Agent Installation

                2. Select Configuration > Environment variables > Edit

                3. Edit the value for environment variable AWS_PROTECT_FN_NAME to include the log forwarder function name/arn in the comma separated list of Lambda functions.

                4. Save the changes and continue when update completes

                5. Navigate to Test tab

                6. Add an event {} and select Test to run the Policy Agent function

                7. Verify Log forwarder function was updated to use the policy layer by inspecting the log output. Logs should include the following:

                  
                  [INFO] 2024-07-09 18:58:04,793.793Z 622d374b-1f73-4123-9a38-abc61973adef iap_agent.policy_deployer:Updating lambda [Protegrity_LogForwarder_<stack ID>] to use layer version [arn:aws:lambda:<aws region>:<aws account number>:layer:Protegrity_Layer_<layer name>:<layer version>]
                  

                Test Full Log Forwarder Installation

                Install and configure Protegrity Agent, Protector, and Log Forwarder components.

                1. Send a protect operation to the protector using a data element or user which will result in audit log generation

                2. Navigate to the CloudWatch log group for the Protect function

                3. Select the log stream for the test operation and scroll to the latest logs

                4. Expect to see a log similar to the below:

                  
                  [2024-07-09T19:28:23.158] [INFO] [kinesis-external-sink.cpp:51] Sending 2 logs to Kinesis ...
                  [2024-07-09T19:28:23.218] [INFO] [aws-utils.cpp:206] Kinesis send time: 0.060s
                  
                5. Navigate to the CloudWatch log group for the Log Forwarder function

                6. Expect to see a new log stream - it may take several minutes for the stream to start

                7. Select the new stream and scroll to the most recent logs in the stream

                8. Expect to see a log similar to the below:

                  
                  [2024-07-09T19:32:31.648] [INFO] [kinesis-log-aggregation-format.cpp:77] Aggregated 1 records into 0 aggregated, 1 forwarded and 0 failed records
                  

                Troubleshooting

                Error

                Action

                Log forwarder log contains severe level secrets permissions error:

                [SEVERE] User: <arn> is not authorized to perform: secretsmanager:
                GetSecretValue on resource: <secret name> because no identity-based
                policy allows the secretsmanager:GetSecretValue action
                
                1. Verify the permission policy/role attached to the log forwarder function has secretsmanager:GetSecretValue permission for the insights esa user credentials secret.
                2. Consult sections Configure ESA Audit Store Credentials and Create Audit Log Forwarder IAM Execution Policy

                When testing log forwarder as described in Test Log Forwarder Installation, response contains policy decryption error:

                
                {
                  "error_msg": "Failed to decrypt the policy. Please verify
                    that the function has access to the key service and the key.",
                  "success": false
                }
                
                1. Verify the permission policy/role attached to the log forwarder function has kms:Decrypt permission for KMS key used to encrypt the Protegrity security policy.
                2. Consult section Create Audit Log Forwarder IAM Execution Policy

                Cloudformation stack creation fails with error:

                
                The provided execution role does not have permissions to call
                [CreateNetworkInterface|DescribeNetworkInterfaces|DeleteNetworkInterface]
                on EC2 (Service: Lambda, Status Code: 400, Request ID: <request id>)"
                (RequestToken: <request token>, HandlerErrorCode: InvalidRequest)
                
                1. Verify the permission policy/role attached to the log forwarder function has ec2:CreateNetworkInterface, ec2:DescribeNetworkInterfaces, ec2:DeleteNetworkInterface permissions
                2. Consult section Create Audit Log Forwarder IAM Execution Policy

                Severe level kinesis permissions log message in protector function:

                
                [SEVERE] Kinesis stream client returned 400 error with error message:
                User: <function arn> is not authorized to perform: kinesis:PutRecords
                on resource: <kinesis stream arn> because no identity-based policy
                allows the kinesis:PutRecords action
                
                1. Verify the permission policy/role attached to the protector function has kinesis:PutRecords permission
                2. Consult section Add Kinesis Put Record permission to the Protect Function IAM Role

                TLS errors reported in log forwarder function logs:

                
                [error] [tls] <error message>
                
                1. If ESA is using self-signed certificate, verify the correct ESA certificate has been given in the format described in Certificates on ESA

                3.6 -

                Prerequisites

                RequirementsDescription
                Protegrity distribution and installation scriptsThese artifacts are provided by Protegrity
                Protegrity ESA 10.0+The Cloud VPC must be able to obtain network access to the ESA
                AWS AccountRecommend creating a new sub-account for Protegrity Serverless
                Redshift cluster (Enterprise Edition)Must be in the same region as Protegrity Protect Lambda

                3.7 -

                AWS Services

                The following table describes the AWS services that may be a part of your Protegrity installation.

                Service

                Description

                Lambda

                Provides serverless compute for Protegrity protection operations and the ESA integration to fetch policy updates or deliver audit logs.

                KMS

                Provides secrets for envelope policy encryption/decryption for Protegrity.

                Secrets Manager

                Provides secrets management for the ESA credentials.

                S3

                Intermediate storage location for the encrypted ESA policy layer.

                Kinesis

                Required if Log Forwarder is to be deployed. Amazon Kinesis is used to batch audit logs sent from protector function to ESA.

                VPC & NAT Gateway

                Optional. Provides a private subnet to communicate with an on-prem ESA.

                CloudWatch

                Application and audit logs, performance monitoring, and alerts. Scheduling for the policy agent.

                3.8 -

                Required Skills and Abilities

                RequirementsDescription
                AWS Account AdministratorTo run CloudFormation (or perform steps manually), create/configure a VPC and IAM permissions.
                Protegrity AdministratorThe ESA credentials required to extract the policy for the Policy Agent
                Redshift AdministratorAccount Admin access required to setup access
                Network AdministratorTo open firewall to access ESA and evaluate AWS network setup

                4 - Understanding Redshift Objects

                Key concepts in understanding the Protegrity Cloud Protect with Redshift.

                External Functions

                Redshift provides an External Function capability that is used to call out to a process external to Redshift. In this solution, the external service is Protegrity Redshift Protector, an AWS Lambda for re-identification operations.

                Function Naming Convention

                The request payload header indicates the current user context making the Protegrity operation through an SQL request. Protegrity also requires the type of operation and the security policy element name. Protegrity Serverless provides a UDF function naming convention to provide this additional context.

                The function name convention requires the prefix pty, the type of operation (protect or unprotect), and the ESA policy element name. The three tokens are separated by underscores. Additional underscores are interpreted as part of the element name. (e.g. pty_protect_tok_deSSN).

                The UDF naming convention is as follows.

                TokenDescriptionValid Options
                PrefixRequired to indicate this methodpty
                operationType of operationprotect, unprotect
                Element nameESA element nameValid ESA element name (can contain additional underscores)

                For example, the following UDF will perform an unprotect using the alpha element policy.

                CREATE OR REPLACE EXTERNAL FUNCTION pty_unprotect_alpha(varchar)
                RETURNS varchar VOLATILE lambda '<replace_with_protect_function_name>:Production' iam_role 'arn:aws:iam::<you-aws-account-number>:role/<role-name>'
                

                Mapping File

                Protegrity Serverless provides an additional method for mapping UDF function names to operations and security policy elements through a JSON mapping file. This method is recommended when either custom naming conventions are needed or element names do not conform to Redshift’s function naming validation rules. Here is an example.

                The mapping file must be provided in the same S3 bucket as policy export: AWS_POLICY_S3_BUCKET

                {
                  "myudf_unp_city":
                    {
                      "Operation": "unprotect",
                      "Element": "deCity”
                    },
                  "myudf_pro_dob": {
                      "Operation": "protect",
                      "Element": "deBirthdate"
                    },
                    ...
                }
                

                The example mapping above would cause Protegrity Serverless to perform an unprotect on the deCity security element for the requests made from the myudf_unp_city UDF function within Redshift.

                4.1 -

                External Functions

                Redshift provides an External Function capability that is used to call out to a process external to Redshift. In this solution, the external service is Protegrity Redshift Protector, an AWS Lambda for re-identification operations.

                4.2 -

                Function Naming Convention

                The request payload header indicates the current user context making the Protegrity operation through an SQL request. Protegrity also requires the type of operation and the security policy element name. Protegrity Serverless provides a UDF function naming convention to provide this additional context.

                The function name convention requires the prefix pty, the type of operation (protect or unprotect), and the ESA policy element name. The three tokens are separated by underscores. Additional underscores are interpreted as part of the element name. (e.g. pty_protect_tok_deSSN).

                The UDF naming convention is as follows.

                TokenDescriptionValid Options
                PrefixRequired to indicate this methodpty
                operationType of operationprotect, unprotect
                Element nameESA element nameValid ESA element name (can contain additional underscores)

                For example, the following UDF will perform an unprotect using the alpha element policy.

                CREATE OR REPLACE EXTERNAL FUNCTION pty_unprotect_alpha(varchar)
                RETURNS varchar VOLATILE lambda '<replace_with_protect_function_name>:Production' iam_role 'arn:aws:iam::<you-aws-account-number>:role/<role-name>'
                

                4.3 -

                Mapping File

                Protegrity Serverless provides an additional method for mapping UDF function names to operations and security policy elements through a JSON mapping file. This method is recommended when either custom naming conventions are needed or element names do not conform to Redshift’s function naming validation rules. Here is an example.

                The mapping file must be provided in the same S3 bucket as policy export: AWS_POLICY_S3_BUCKET

                {
                  "myudf_unp_city":
                    {
                      "Operation": "unprotect",
                      "Element": "deCity”
                    },
                  "myudf_pro_dob": {
                      "Operation": "protect",
                      "Element": "deBirthdate"
                    },
                    ...
                }
                

                The example mapping above would cause Protegrity Serverless to perform an unprotect on the deCity security element for the requests made from the myudf_unp_city UDF function within Redshift.

                5 - Performance

                Benchmarks and performance tuning

                  Performance Considerations

                  The following factors may cause variation in real performance versus benchmarks:

                  • Cold startup: The Lambda spends additional time on the initial invocation to decrypt and load the policy into memory. This time can vary between 400 ms and 1200 ms depending on the policy size. Once the Lambda is initialized, subsequent “warm executions” should process quickly.
                  • Size of policy: The size of the policy impacts cold start performance. Larger policies take more time to initialize.
                  • Lambda memory: AWS provides more virtual cores based on the memory configuration. The initial configuration of 1728 MB provides a good tradeoff between performance and cost with the benchmarked policy. Memory can be increased to optimize for your individual cases.
                  • Cluster size: Cluster size may make a significant difference depending on the workload.
                  • Number of security operations (protect or unprotect).
                  • Lambda concurrency and burst quotas: AWS limits the number of concurrent executions and how quickly lambda can scale to meet demand. This is discussed in an upcoming section of the document.
                  • Size of data element: Operations on larger text consume time.

                  Sample Benchmarks

                  The following benchmarks were performed against different cluster sizes. These are median times of approximately five runs each. The query unprotected six columns per row (first_name, last_name, email, postal_code, ssn, iban):

                  Rows x Cols# Opsdc2.large (24 nodes)ra3.4xl (3 nodes)ra3.4xl (7 nodes)ra3.16xl (7 nodes)
                  1M x 6 cols6M1.61.71.51.2
                  10M x 6 cols60M6.06.32.83.3
                  100M x 6 cols600M44.349.823.415.1

                  Lambda Tuning

                  AWS maintains quotas for Lambda concurrent execution. Two of these quotas impact concurrency and compete with other Lambdas in the same account and region:

                  The Concurrent executions quota cap is the maximum number of Lambda instances that can serve requests for an account and region. The default AWS quota may be inadequate based on peak concurrency based on the table in the previous section. This quota can be increased with an AWS support ticket.

                  The Burst concurrency quota limits the rate at which Lambda will scale to accommodate demand. This quota is also per account and region. The burst quota cannot be adjusted. AWS will quickly scale until the burst limit is reached. After the burst limit is reached, functions will scale at a reduced rate per minute (e.g. 500). If no Lambda instances can serve a request, the request will fail with a 429 Too Many Requests response. Redshift will generally retry until all requests succeed but may abort if a high percentage of failed responses occur.

                  The burst limit is a fixed value and varies significantly by AWS region. The highest burst (3,000) is currently available in the following regions: US West (Oregon), US East (N.Virginia), and Europe (Ireland). Other regions can burst between 500 and 1,000. It is recommended to select a Redshift AWS region with the highest burst limits.

                  Concurrency Troubleshooting

                  Hitting up against quota limits may indicate that quota adjustments are required. Exceeding quota limits may cause a Redshift query to fail or reduce performance. In the worst case, significant throttling can impact the performance of all your Lambda services in the region.

                  Redshift is tolerant of a certain ratio of failed requests and automatically retries. If a high percentage of requests fail, then the query may abort and the last error code will display in the console. For example, 429 Too Many Requests.

                  CloudWatch Metrics can be manually enabled on the Lambda to reveal if quotas are being reached. Metrics aggregate errors into two buckets that are 4xx. CloudWatch logs can be used to access the actual error code.

                  Log Forwarder Performance

                  Log forwarder architecture is optimized to minimize the amount of connections and reduce the overall network bandwidth required to send audit logs to ESA. This is achieved with batching and aggregation taking place on two levels. The first level is in protect function instances, where audit logs from consecutive requests to an instance are batched and aggregated. The second level of batching takes place in Amazon Kinesis Stream where log records from different protect function instances are additionally batched and sent to log forwarder function where they are aggregated. This section shows how to configure the deployment to accommodate different patterns of anticipated audit log stream. It also shows how to monitor deployment resources to detect problems before audit records are lost.

                      

                  • Protector Cloud Formation Parameters

                    • AuditLogFlushInterval: Determines the minimum amount of time required for the audit log to be sent to Amazon Kinesis. Changing flush interval may affect the level of aggregation, which in turn may result in different number of connections and different data rates to Amazon Kinesis. Default value is 30 seconds.

                      Increasing the flush interval may result in higher aggregation of audit logs, in fewer connections to Amazon Kinesis, in higher latency of audit logs arriving to ESA and in higher data throughput.

                      Lowering the flush interval may result in lower aggregation of audit logs, in more connections to Amazon Kinesis, in lower latency of audit logs arriving to ESA and in lower data throughput.

                      It is not recommended to reduce the flush interval from default value in production environment as it may overload the Amazon Kinesis service. However, it may be beneficial to reduce flush interval during testing to make audit records appear on ESA faster.

                        

                  • Log Forwarder Cloud Formation Parameters

                    • Amazon KinesisLogStreamShardCount: The number of shards represents the level of parallel streams in the Amazon Kinesis and it is proportional to the throughput capacity of the stream. If the number of shards is too low and the volume of audit logs is too high, Amazon Kinesis service may be overloaded and some audit records sent from protect function may be lost.

                      Default value is 10, however you are advised to test with a production-like load to determine whether this is sufficient or not.

                    • Amazon KinesisLogStreamRetentionPeriodHours: The time for the audit records to be retained in Amazon Kinesis log stream in cases where log forwarder function is unable to read records from the Kinesis stream or send records to ESA, for example due to a connectivity outage. Amazon Kinesis will retain failed audit records and retry periodically until connectivity with ESA is restored or retention period expires.

                      Default value is 24 hours, however you are advised to review this value to align it with your Recovery Time Objective and Recovery Point Objective SLAs.

                        

                  • Monitoring Log Forwarder Resources

                    • Amazon Kinesis Stream Metrics: Any positive value in Amazon Kinesis PutRecords throttled records metric indicates that audit logs rate from protect function is too high. The recommended action is to increase the Amazon KinesisLogStreamShardCount or optionally increase the AuditLogFlushInterval.

                    • Log Forwarder Function CloudWatch Logs: If log forwarder function is unable to send logs to ESA, it will log the following message:

                      [SEVERE] Dropped records: x.
                      
                    • Protect Function CloudWatch Logs: If protect function is unable to send logs to Amazon Kinesis, it will log the following message:

                      [SEVERE] Amazon Kinesis error, retrying in x ms (retry: y/z) ..."
                      

                      Any dropped audit log records will be reported with the following log message:

                      [SEVERE] Failed to send x/y audit logs to Amazon Kinesis.
                      

                  5.1 -

                  Concurrency Troubleshooting

                  Hitting up against quota limits may indicate that quota adjustments are required. Exceeding quota limits may cause a Redshift query to fail or reduce performance. In the worst case, significant throttling can impact the performance of all your Lambda services in the region.

                  Redshift is tolerant of a certain ratio of failed requests and automatically retries. If a high percentage of requests fail, then the query may abort and the last error code will display in the console. For example, 429 Too Many Requests.

                  CloudWatch Metrics can be manually enabled on the Lambda to reveal if quotas are being reached. Metrics aggregate errors into two buckets that are 4xx. CloudWatch logs can be used to access the actual error code.

                  5.2 -

                  Lambda Tuning

                  AWS maintains quotas for Lambda concurrent execution. Two of these quotas impact concurrency and compete with other Lambdas in the same account and region:

                  The Concurrent executions quota cap is the maximum number of Lambda instances that can serve requests for an account and region. The default AWS quota may be inadequate based on peak concurrency based on the table in the previous section. This quota can be increased with an AWS support ticket.

                  The Burst concurrency quota limits the rate at which Lambda will scale to accommodate demand. This quota is also per account and region. The burst quota cannot be adjusted. AWS will quickly scale until the burst limit is reached. After the burst limit is reached, functions will scale at a reduced rate per minute (e.g. 500). If no Lambda instances can serve a request, the request will fail with a 429 Too Many Requests response. Redshift will generally retry until all requests succeed but may abort if a high percentage of failed responses occur.

                  The burst limit is a fixed value and varies significantly by AWS region. The highest burst (3,000) is currently available in the following regions: US West (Oregon), US East (N.Virginia), and Europe (Ireland). Other regions can burst between 500 and 1,000. It is recommended to select a Redshift AWS region with the highest burst limits.

                  5.3 -

                  Sample Benchmarks

                  The following benchmarks were performed against different cluster sizes. These are median times of approximately five runs each. The query unprotected six columns per row (first_name, last_name, email, postal_code, ssn, iban):

                  Rows x Cols# Opsdc2.large (24 nodes)ra3.4xl (3 nodes)ra3.4xl (7 nodes)ra3.16xl (7 nodes)
                  1M x 6 cols6M1.61.71.51.2
                  10M x 6 cols60M6.06.32.83.3
                  100M x 6 cols600M44.349.823.415.1

                  5.4 -

                  Performance Considerations

                  The following factors may cause variation in real performance versus benchmarks:

                  • Cold startup: The Lambda spends additional time on the initial invocation to decrypt and load the policy into memory. This time can vary between 400 ms and 1200 ms depending on the policy size. Once the Lambda is initialized, subsequent “warm executions” should process quickly.
                  • Size of policy: The size of the policy impacts cold start performance. Larger policies take more time to initialize.
                  • Lambda memory: AWS provides more virtual cores based on the memory configuration. The initial configuration of 1728 MB provides a good tradeoff between performance and cost with the benchmarked policy. Memory can be increased to optimize for your individual cases.
                  • Cluster size: Cluster size may make a significant difference depending on the workload.
                  • Number of security operations (protect or unprotect).
                  • Lambda concurrency and burst quotas: AWS limits the number of concurrent executions and how quickly lambda can scale to meet demand. This is discussed in an upcoming section of the document.
                  • Size of data element: Operations on larger text consume time.

                  6 - Audit Logging

                  Audit log description/formatting

                    Audit Logging

                    Audit records and application logs stream to Amazon CloudWatch Logs or optionally be sent to ESA. Cloud Protect uses a JSON format for audit records that is described in the following sections.

                    You can analyze and alert on audit records using Protegrity ESA or Amazon CloudWatch. Third-party solutions may be used if they are supported by Amazon Cloudwatch or AWS Lambda logging extensions. For more information about forwarding your audit records to ESA, contact Protegrity. For more information about Amazon CloudWatch, refer to the Amazon CloudWatch User Guide.

                    For more information about audit records, refer to the Protegrity Analytics Guide.

                    Audit record fields

                    The audit record format has been altered in version 3.1 of the protector to provide more information.

                    FieldDescription
                    additional_info.deployment_idThe deployment_id contains the name of the Protect Function. It is automatically set based on the cloud-specific environment variables assigned to the Protect Function. This allows identifying the Cloud Protect deployment responsible for generating audit log.
                    additional_info.cluster(Optional) Redshift cluster ARN
                    additional_info.descriptionA human-readable message describing the operation
                    additional_info.query_id(Optional) Identifies the query that triggered the operation
                    additional_info.request_id(Optional) AWS Lambda request identifier
                    cntNumber of operations, may be aggregated
                    correlationid(Deprecated) Use additional_info instead
                    levelLog severity, one of: SUCCESS, WARNING, ERROR, EXCEPTION
                    logtypeAlways “Protection”
                    origin.ipThe private IP address of the compute resource that operates the Protect Function and is responsible for generating the log entry.
                    origin.hostnameHostname of the system that generated the log entry
                    origin.time_utcUTC timestamp when the log entry was generated
                    protection.audit_codeAudit code of the protect operation; see the log return codes table in the Protegrity Troubleshooting Guide
                    protection.dataelementData element used for the policy operation
                    protection.datastoreName of the data store corresponding to the deployed policy
                    protection.mask_setting(Optional) Mask setting from policy management
                    protection.operationOperation type, one of: Protect, Unprotect, Reprotect
                    protection.policy_userUser that performed the operation
                    protector.core_versionInternal core component version
                    protector.familyAlways “cp” for Cloud Protect
                    protector.lambda_versionProtector Lambda application version.
                    protector.pcc_versionInternal pcc component version
                    protector.vendorIdentifies the cloud vendor and the database vendor
                    protector.versionProtector version number
                    signature.checksumHash value of the signature key ID used to sign the log message when the log is generated
                    signature.key_idKey used to sign the log message when the log is generated

                    Example Audit Records

                    The following are sample audit messages:

                    Protect Success:

                    {
                          "additional_info": {
                            "deployment_id": "Protegrity-Protect-function-deployment-id",
                            "description": "Data protect operation was successful.",
                            "query_id": "sf-query-id:01978dbc-0582-d7e4-0000-002a3603a20d",
                            "request_id": "8476a536-e9f4-11e8-9739-2dfe598c3fcd"
                          },
                          "cnt": 4000,
                          "correlationid": "sf-query-id:01978dbc-0582-d7e4-0000-002a3603a20d",
                          "logtype": "Protection",
                          "level": "SUCESS",
                          "origin": {
                            "hostname": "localhost",
                            "ip": "127.0.0.1",
                            "time_utc": 1635363966
                          },
                          "protection": {
                            "dataelement": "deAddress",
                            "operation": "Protect",
                            "audit_code": 6,
                            "datastore": "SAMPLE_POLICY",
                            "policy_user": "test_user"
                          },
                          process":{
                            "name":"protect",
                            "id":"13",
                            "module":"coreprovider",
                            "thread_id":"573580544",
                            "user":"sbx_user1051",
                            "platform":"\"Linux_x64\"",
                            "version":"UNKNOWN"
                          },
                          "client": {
                            "ip":"169.254.62.117"
                          },
                          "protector": {
                            "family": "cp",
                            "version": "4.0.0.102",
                            "vendor": "aws.snowflake",
                            "datastore":"SAMPLE_POLICY",
                            "pcc_version": "4.0.0.9",
                            "core_version": "2.1.4+0.g93016.2.1",
                            "lambda_version":"4.0.1"
                          },
                          "signature": {
                            "key_id": "95f5a194-b0a4-4351-a",
                            "checksum": "B324AF7C56944D91C47847A77C0367C594C0B948E7E75654B889571BD4F60A71"
                          }
                        }
                    

                    User permission denied:

                    {
                          "additional_info": {
                            "deployment_id": "Protegrity-Protect-function-deployment-id",
                            "description": "The user does not have the appropriate permissions to perform the requested operation.",
                            "query_id": "sf-query-id:01978dbc-0582-d7e4-0000-002a3603a20d",
                            "request_id": "8476a536-e9f4-11e8-9739-2dfe598c3fcd"
                          },
                          "cnt": 4000,
                          "correlationid": "sf-query-id:01978dbc-0582-d7e4-0000-002a3603a20d",
                          "logtype": "Protection",
                          "level": "ERROR",
                          "origin": {
                            "hostname": "localhost",
                            "ip": "127.0.0.1",
                            "time_utc": 1635363966
                          },
                          "protection": {
                            "dataelement": "deAddress",
                            "operation": "Protect",
                            "audit_code": 3,
                            "datastore": "SAMPLE_POLICY",
                            "policy_user": "test_user"
                          },
                          process":{
                            "name":"protect",
                            "id":"13",
                            "module":"coreprovider",
                            "thread_id":"573580544",
                            "user":"sbx_user1051",
                            "platform":"\"Linux_x64\"",
                            "version":"UNKNOWN"
                          },
                          "client": {
                            "ip":"169.254.62.117"
                          },
                          "protector": {
                            "family": "cp",
                            "version": "4.0.0.102",
                            "vendor": "aws.snowflake",
                            "datastore":"SAMPLE_POLICY",
                            "pcc_version": "4.0.0.9",
                            "core_version": "2.1.4+0.g93016.2.1",
                            "lambda_version":"4.0.1"
                          },
                          "signature": {
                            "key_id": "95f5a194-b0a4-4351-a",
                            "checksum": "A216797C56944D91C47847A77C0367C594C0B948E7E75654B889571BD4F60A71"
                          }
                        }
                    

                    Data element not found:

                    {
                          "additional_info": {
                            "deployment_id": "Protegrity-Protect-function-deployment-id",
                            "description": "The data element could not be found in the policy.",
                            "query_id": "sf-query-id:01978dbc-0582-d7e4-0000-002a3603a20d",
                            "request_id": "8476a536-e9f4-11e8-9739-2dfe598c3fcd"
                          },
                          "cnt": 4000,
                          "correlationid": "sf-query-id:01978dbc-0582-d7e4-0000-002a3603a20d",
                          "logtype": "Protection",
                          "level": "ERROR",
                          "origin": {
                            "hostname": "localhost",
                            "ip": "127.0.0.1",
                            "time_utc": 1635363966
                          },
                          "protection": {
                            "dataelement": "deAddress",
                            "operation": "Protect",
                            "audit_code": 2,
                            "datastore": "SAMPLE_POLICY",
                            "policy_user": "test_user"
                          },
                          process":{
                            "name":"protect",
                            "id":"13",
                            "module":"coreprovider",
                            "thread_id":"573580544",
                            "user":"sbx_user1051",
                            "platform":"\"Linux_x64\"",
                            "version":"UNKNOWN"
                          },
                          "client": {
                            "ip":"169.254.62.117"
                          },
                          "protector": {
                            "family": "cp",
                            "version": "4.0.0.102",
                            "vendor": "aws.snowflake",
                            "datastore":"SAMPLE_POLICY",
                            "pcc_version": "4.0.0.9",
                            "core_version": "2.1.4+0.g93016.2.1",
                            "lambda_version":"4.0.1"
                          },
                          "signature": {
                            "key_id": "95f5a194-b0a4-4351-a",
                            "checksum": "AF09217C56944D91C47847A77C0367C594C0B948E7E75654B889571BD4F60A71"
                          }
                        }
                    

                    7 - No Access Behavior

                    Describes the result of various policy configurations with no access operations

                    No Access Behavior

                    The security policy maintains a No Access Operation, configured in an ESA, which determines the response for unauthorized unprotect requests.

                    The following table describes the result returned in the response for the various no access unprotect permissions.

                    No Access OperationData Returned
                    Nullnull
                    Protected(protected value)
                    ExceptionQuery will fail with an exception

                    8 - Known Limitations

                    Known product limitations.

                    Known Limitations

                    Known product limitations:

                    • FPE is supported only for ASCII values.
                    • Only the protect and unprotect operations are supported. The reprotect operation is not currently supported.
                    • The BIGINT data types are not protected/unprotected accurately. Use String instead.
                    • The FLOAT8 (8-byte float) data type is not supported. Use String instead.
                    • The timestamp data type is not supported.

                    9 - Upgrading To The Latest Version

                    Instructions for upgrading the protector.

                      Download the Latest Version

                      You can download the latest version of the deployment package from https://my.protegrity.com. Navigate to Data Protection > Cloud Protect to download the latest version.

                      After downloading the deployment package from the Protegrity Portal, unzip the package to extract the artifact files. In the AWS Console, navigate to the S3 bucket that was previously created to upload deployment artifacts (see: Create S3 bucket for Installing Artifacts).

                      Upload the following artifacts to the S3 bucket:

                      - -
                      • protegrity-protect-<version>.zip
                      • protegrity-agent-<version>.zip
                      • protegrity-external-extension-<version>.zip
                      • protegrity-sample-policy-<version>.zip
                      • protegrity-protect-<version>.zip
                      • protegrity-agent-<version>.zip
                      • protegrity-external-extension-<version>.zip
                      • protegrity-sample-policy-<version>.zip
                      • protegrity-protect-<version>.zip
                      • protegrity-agent-<version>.zip
                      • protegrity-external-extension-<version>.zip
                      • protegrity-sample-policy-<version>.zip
                      • protegrity-athena-protect-udfs-<version>.jar
                      • protegrity-external-extension-<version>.zip
                      • protegrity-agent-<version>.zip
                      • protegrity-sample-policy-<version>.zip

                      If the release version matches your existing deployment, you don’t need to upload it again. Save the following artifacts on your local system so that you have them available during the next steps:

                      - -
                      • pty_protect_cf.json
                      • pty_agent_cf.json
                      • pty_protect_cf.json
                      • pty_agent_cf.json
                      • pty_protect_api_cf.json
                      • pty_agent_cf.json
                      • pty_log_forwarder_cf.json
                      • pty_athena_protect_cf.json
                      • pty_agent_cf.json

                      Perform the following steps to upgrade the Agent Lambda and Protect Lambda separately.

                      Disable Protegrity Agent Function CloudWatch Event Rule

                      Cloud Watch Event Rule is used to periodically run Protegrity Agent Function to synchronize policy from ESA. This functionality is optional when deploying Protegrity Serverless Solution. If the Event Rule is enabled, it must be disabled temporarily for the time of the upgrade process.

                      Follow the steps below to determine if your deployment uses Event Rule and disable it.

                      1. Go to AWS Cloud Formation and select existing Protegrity deployment stack.

                      2. Select Resources tab from the top portion of the screen.

                      3. Check if there is a resource with ScheduledRule LogicalID. If there is no such resource you can skip to Upgrading Policy Agent Lambda section. If the scheduled rule is there, continue with the next steps in this section.

                      4. Click on the Physical ID link in the ScheduledRule row. The link opens Policy Agent Event Rule configuration.

                      5. Select Disable from the top-right portion of the screen. This will disable the rule. You will re-enable it after the upgrade process is complete.

                      Upgrading Policy Agent Lambda

                      1. Go to AWS Lambda console and select existing Protegrity Agent Lambda.

                      2. Click Actions in top right portion of the screen. Select Publish new version. Click Publish. The version of Agent Lambda you just created will serve as restore point in the case you needed to rollback the upgrade.

                      3. Go to Lambda Configuration > Environment variables.

                      4. Record environment variables values. You will use them later to configure upgraded Lambda Function. You can use the aws cli command below to save the function variables into the local json file:

                        aws lambda get-function-configuration --function-name \
                        arn:aws:lambda:<aws_region>:<aws_account>:function:<function_name> \
                        --query Environment > <function_name>_env_config.json
                        
                      5. Go to AWS Cloud Formation and select existing Protegrity Agent deployment stack.

                      6. Select Update. Check Replace current template > Upload a template file.

                      7. Upload pty_agent_cf.json file and select Next.

                      8. Click Next until Review window and then select Update stack.

                      9. Wait for the Cloud Formation to complete.

                      10. Navigate back to Agent Lambda Function.

                      1. Go to Configuration > Environment variables. Replace placeholder values with values recorded in previous step. Alternatively, you can run the following aws cli command to update function configuration using json file saved in the previous steps:

                        aws lambda update-function-configuration --function-name \
                        arn:aws:lambda:<aws_region>:<aws_account>:function:<function_name> \
                        --environment file://./<function_name>_env_config.json
                        
                      2. If you are upgrading from versions prior to v3.0, backup and remove existing policy from the bucket defined by AWS_POLICY_S3_BUCKET property, so that the policy can be re-downloaded and re-encrypted with new ‘key commitment’ feature.

                      3. If you are upgrading from version prior to 1.6.1 please follow the steps below, otherwise the upgrade process is completed.

                      4. From AWS Console, navigate to IAM > Policies

                      5. Search for the Agent Lambda IAM Policy created in Create Agent Lambda IAM policy

                      6. Click on the policy, then select Edit Policy. Select JSON tab.

                      7. Add the following statement to the list of policy statements.

                        
                        {
                          "Sid": "LambdaGetConfiguration",
                          "Effect": "Allow",
                          "Action": [
                              "lambda:GetFunctionConfiguration"
                          ],
                          "Resource": [
                              "arn:aws:lambda:*:*:function:*"
                          ]
                        }
                        
                      8. Click Review Policy, then Save Changes. Wait for the changes to save.

                      Upgrading Log Forwarder Lambda

                      • Publish Log Forwarder Lambda Version

                        Publishing a version of the Log Forwarder Lambda allows to roll-back to pre-existing version if upgrade fails

                        1. Go to AWS Lambda console and select existing Protegrity Log Forwarder Lambda.

                        2. Click Actions in top right portion of the screen. Select Publish new version. Click Publish.

                        3. Record the Lambda version number. It will be displayed at the top of the screen. You can also retrieve it from the Lambda function view, under Versions tab.

                          Log Forwarder Lambda version number for roll-backs: ___________________

                      • Disable Kinesis Trigger

                        Disabling Kinesis trigger ensures there are no unprocessed or re-processed events while function is upgraded.

                        1. Go to AWS Lambda console and select existing Protegrity Log Forwarder Lambda.
                        2. Select Configuration tab > Triggers
                        3. Check Kinesis trigger and click Edit button
                        4. Uncheck Activate trigger and click Save
                        5. Wait for function to stop processing events by monitoring function in Monitor tab
                      • Upgrade Forwarder Lambda Version

                        Upgrade Log Forwarder function with new code

                        1. Go to AWS Cloud Formation and select existing Protegrity Log Forwarder deployment stack.
                        2. Select Update Stack > Make a direct update.
                        3. Select Replace existing template > Upload a template file.
                        4. Upload pty_log_forwarder_cf file and select Next.
                        5. Click Next until Review window and then select Update stack.
                        6. Wait for the Cloud Formation to complete.
                      • Enable Kinesis Trigger

                        1. Go to AWS Lambda console and select existing Protegrity Log Forwarder Lambda.
                        2. Select Configuration tab > Triggers
                        3. Check Kinesis trigger and click Edit button
                        4. Check Activate trigger and click Save Log Forwarder function will now start processing events from where it left off when Kinesis trigger was disabled.
                      • Monitor and roll-back

                        Monitor Log Forwarder function for errors in its CloudWatch logs and in Montior tab. To roll back function to the previous version if any errors occur follow these steps:

                        1. Go to AWS Lambda console and select existing Protegrity Log Forwarder Lambda.

                        2. Select Configuration tab > Triggers

                        3. Expand Details section of Kinesis trigger and record UUID value

                        4. Execute the following AWS CLI command to move Kinesis trigger to previous version of Log Forwarder Lambda that was created earlier and recorded as Log Forwarder Lambda version number for roll-backs. Substitute kinesis-mapping-uuid, log-forwarder-function-name, version-for-roll-backs with your values:

                          
                          aws lambda update-event-source-mapping --uuid <kinesis-mapping-uuid> --function-name <log-forwarder-function-name>:<version-for-roll-backs>
                          
                        5. Find Kinesis trigger attached to previous version of Log Forwarder Lambda by navigating Versions tab > Version number link in the Versions column Kinesis trigger is now moved to previous version of Log Forwarder Lambda function.

                      Upgrading Protect Lambda

                      Diagram below illustrates upgrade steps.

                      Snowflake Function Upgrade Steps

                      Redshift Function Upgrade Steps

                      Cloud API Function Upgrade Steps

                      Athena Function Upgrade Steps

                      • Publish Protect Lambda Version

                        Publishing a version of the Protect Lambda allows updating it without interruptions to the existing traffic.

                        1. Go to AWS Lambda console and select existing Protegrity Protect Lambda.

                        2. Go to Lambda Configuration > Environment variables.

                        3. Record environment variables values. You will use them later to configure upgraded Lambda Function. You can use the aws cli command below to save the function variables into the local json file:

                          aws lambda get-function-configuration --function-name \
                          arn:aws:lambda:<aws_region>:<aws_account>:function:<function_name> \
                          --query Environment > <function_name>_env_config.json
                          
                        4. Click Actions in top right portion of the screen. Select Publish new version. Click Publish.

                        5. Record the Lambda version number. It will be displayed at the top of the screen. You can also retrieve it from the Lambda function view, under Versions tab.

                          Protect Lambda version number: ___________________

                        6. If you are upgrading a Cloud Protect Redshift version 1.x to 2.x/3x, you must recreate your Redshift external function definitions with Protect Lambda Function version appended to the Lambda Function name. See example below.

                          CREATE OR REPLACE EXTERNAL FUNCTION PTY_PROTECT_TEST ( val varchar )
                              RETURNS varchar
                              VOLATILE lambda
                              'Protegrity_Protect_test:<protect_lambda_version_number>' iam_role
                              'arn:aws:iam::123456789212:role/example_role';
                          
                      • Run protect service upgrade

                        In this step, the Protect service including Lambda $LATEST version will be updated using Cloud Formation template. The Lambda version created in previous step will be used to serve existing traffic during the upgrade process.

                        1. Go to AWS Cloud Formation and select existing Protegrity deployment stack.

                        2. Select Update. Check Replace current template > Upload a template file.

                        3. Upload pty_protect_cf.json file and select Next.

                        4. Update ProtectFunctionProductionVersion parameter with Protect Lambda version number recorded in step 3.

                        5. Click Next until Review window and then select Update stack.

                        6. Wait for the Cloud Formation to complete.

                        7. Go back to Lambda console and select Protect Lambda.

                        8. Go to Configuration > Environment variables. Replace placeholder values with values recorded in previous step. Alternatively, you can run the following aws cli command to update function configuration using json file saved in the previous steps:

                          aws lambda update-function-configuration --function-name \
                          arn:aws:lambda:<aws_region>:<aws_account>:function:<function_name> \
                          --environment file://./<function_name>_env_config.json
                          
                        9. Navigate to Aliases tab. Verify that Production alias points to the lambda version you specified in the cloud formation template.

                        10. The upgraded Protect Lambda is configured with a sample policy. Run Agent Lambda Function before continuing with next steps.

                      • Finalize upgrade

                        In this step, the Protect Lambda will be configured to serve traffic using $LATEST version upgraded in the previous step.

                        1. Go back to Protegrity AWS Cloud Formation deployment stack.

                        2. Select Update. Check Use Current template.

                        3. Update ProtectFunctionProductionVersion parameter with the following value: $LATEST.

                        4. Click Next until Review window and then select Update stack.

                        5. Go back to Lambda console and select Protect Lambda.

                        6. From the Lambda console, verify that Latest alias points to $LATEST version.

                        7. Test your function to make sure it works as expected.

                        8. If you are upgrading a Cloud Protect Redshift version 1.x to 2.x/3x, you must recreate your Redshift external function definitions with Protect Lambda Function version appended to the Lambda Function name. See example below.

                          CREATE OR REPLACE EXTERNAL FUNCTION PTY_PROTECT_TEST ( val varchar )
                              RETURNS varchar
                              VOLATILE lambda
                              'Protegrity_Protect_test:Production' iam_role
                              'arn:aws:iam::123456789212:role/example_role';
                          
                        9. If you need to rollback to older version of Protect Lambda, you can re-run the cloud formation with ProtectFunctionProductionVersion parameter set to the previous version of Protect Lambda.

                      Re-enable Protegrity Agent Function CloudWatch Event Rule

                      If the Event Rule was disabled at the beginning of the upgrade process, you must re-enabled it. Follow the steps below to re-enable Policy Agent Event rule.

                      1. Go to the Protegrity Agent Cloud Formation Stack.

                      2. Select Resources tab from the top portion of the screen.

                      3. Click on the Physical ID link in the ScheduledRule row. The link opens Policy Agent Event Rule configuration.

                      4. Select Enable from the top-right portion of the screen. This will enable the rule. You will re-enable it after the upgrade process is complete.

                      10 - Appendices

                      Additional references for the protector.

                      10.1 - Installing the Policy Agent and Protector in Different AWS Accounts

                      Example steps to install Agent in a different AWS account than the Protector

                        The Policy Agent Lambda function and Protect Lambda functions can be installed in separate AWS accounts. However, additional configuration is required to authorize the Policy Agent to provision the security policy to a remote Protect Lambda function.

                        Create Agent Lambda IAM policy

                        1. Login to the AWS account that hosts the Protect Lambda function.

                        2. From the AWS IAM console, select Policies > Create Policy.

                        3. Select the JSON tab and copy the following snippet.

                          {
                            "Version": "2012-10-17",
                            "Statement": [
                              {
                                "Sid": "LambdaUpdateFunction",
                                "Effect": "Allow",
                                "Action": [
                                  "lambda:UpdateFunctionConfiguration"
                                ],
                                "Resource": [
                                  "arn:aws:lambda:*:*:function:*"
                                ]
                              },
                              {
                                "Sid": "LambdaReadLayerVersion",
                                "Effect": "Allow",
                                "Action": [
                                  "lambda:GetLayerVersion",
                                  "lambda:ListLayerVersions"
                                ],
                                "Resource": "*"
                              },
                              {
                                "Sid": "LambdaDeleteLayerVersion",
                                "Effect": "Allow",
                                "Action": "lambda:DeleteLayerVersion",
                                "Resource": "arn:aws:lambda:*:*:layer:*:*"
                              },
                              {
                                "Sid": "LambdaPublishLayerVersion",
                                "Effect": "Allow",
                                "Action": "lambda:PublishLayerVersion",
                                "Resource": "arn:aws:lambda:*:*:layer:*"
                              },
                              {
                                "Sid": "S3GetObject",
                                "Effect": "Allow",
                                "Action": [
                                  "s3:GetObject"
                                ],
                                "Resource": "arn:aws:s3:::*/*"
                              },
                              {
                                "Sid": "S3PutObject",
                                "Effect": "Allow",
                                "Action": [
                                  "s3:PutObject"
                                ],
                                "Resource": "arn:aws:s3:::*/*"
                              },
                              {
                                "Sid": "LambdaGetConfiguration",
                                "Effect": "Allow",
                                "Action": [
                                    "lambda:GetFunctionConfiguration"
                                ],
                                "Resource": [
                                    "arn:aws:lambda:*:*:function:*"
                                ]
                              }
                            ]
                          }
                          
                        4. Replace the wildcards (*) with the region, account, and resource name information where required.

                        5. Select Review policy, type in the policy name, and confirm. Record policy name:

                          Agent Lambda Cross Account Policy Name: ___________________

                        Create Policy Agent cross-account IAM Role

                        1. Login to the AWS account that hosts the Protect Lambda function.

                        2. From the AWS IAM console, select Roles > Create Role

                        3. Select AWS Service > Lambda . Proceed to Permissions.

                        4. Select Policy created in the step above. Proceed to Tags.

                        5. Specify Tag, proceed to the final screen. Type in policy name and confirm. Record the name.

                          Policy Agent Cross Account IAM Role Name: ___________________

                        Allow the Policy Agent Cross-Account Role to be Assumed by the Policy Agent IAM Role

                        1. Login to the AWS account that hosts the Protect Lambda function.

                        2. Navigate to the previously created IAM Role (Agent Lambda Cross-Account IAM Role Name).

                        3. Navigate to Trust Relationships > Edit Trust Relationships.

                        4. Modify the Policy Document, replacing the placeholder value indicated in the following snippet as <Agent Lambda IAM Execution Role ARN> with ARN of Agent Lambda IAM Role that was created in Agent Installation.

                          {
                            "Version": "2012-10-17",
                            "Statement": [
                              {
                                "Effect": "Allow",
                          
                             "Principal": {
                          
                                      "AWS": "<Agent Lambda IAM Execution Role Name>"
                          
                                },
                                "Action": "sts:AssumeRole"
                              }
                            ]
                          }
                          
                        5. Click Update Trust Policy.

                        Add Assume Role to the Policy Agent Execution IAM Role

                        1. Login to the AWS account that hosts the Policy Agent.

                        2. Navigate to the Agent Lambda IAM Execution Role that was created in Agent Installation.

                          {
                            "Version": "2012-10-17",
                            "Statement": [
                              {
                                "Effect": "Allow",
                          
                             "Principal": {
                          
                                      "AWS": "<Agent Lambda IAM Execution Role Name>"
                          
                                },
                                "Action": "sts:AssumeRole"
                              }
                            ]
                          }
                          
                        3. Add Inline Policy.

                        4. Modify the Policy Document, replacing the placeholder value indicated in the following snippet as <Agent Lambda Cross-Account IAM ARN> with the value recorded in Create Policy Agent cross-account IAM Role.

                          {
                            "Version": "2012-10-17",
                            "Statement": [
                              {
                                "Effect": "Allow",
                                "Action": [
                                  "sts:AssumeRole"
                                ],
                                "Resource": "<Agent Lambda Cross-Account IAM  ARN>."
                              }
                            ]
                          }
                          
                        5. When you are finished, choose Review Policy.

                        6. On the Review policy page, type a Name, then choose Create Policy.

                        Update the Policy Agent Lambda Configuration

                        1. From the AWS console, navigate to Lambda, and select the Policy Agent Lambda function.

                        2. Select Configuration tab | Environment variables.

                        3. Select Edit and add the following environment variables with the value from Agent Lambda Cross-Account IAM ARN:

                          ParameterValue
                          AWS_ASSUME_ROLEAgent Lambda Cross-Account IAM ARN
                        4. Ensure the values in the Parameters AWS_POLICY_S3_BUCKET, AWS_PROTECT_FN_NAME and AWS_POLICY_LAYER_NAME are all in the Protect Lambda Function AWS Account.

                        5. In case custom VPC hostname configuration is used, you will need to set the ENDPOINT_URL. Refer to Policy Agent - Custom VPC Endpoint Hostname Configuration.

                          AWS_VPC_ENDPOINT_URL

                          <AWS_VPC_ENDPOINT>

                        6. Click Save and Run the Lambda. The Lambda will now assume the Role in Protect Lambda Function AWS Account and update the policy cross accounts.

                        10.2 - Integrating Cloud Protect with PPC (Protegrity Provisioned Cluster)

                        Concepts for integrating with PPC (Protegrity Provisioned Cluster)

                        This guide describes how to configure the Protegrity Policy Agent and Log Forwarder to connect to a Protegrity Provisioned Cluster (PPC), highlighting the differences from connecting to ESA.

                        Key Differences: PPC vs ESA

                        FeatureESA 10.2PPC (this guide)
                        Datastore Key FingerprintOptional/RecommendedRequired
                        CA Certificate on AgentOptional/RecommendedOptional/Recommended
                        CA Certificate on Log ForwarderOptional/RecommendedNot supported
                        Client Certificate Authentication from Log ForwarderOptional/RecommendedNot supported
                        IP AddressESA IP addressPPC address

                        Prerequisites

                        • Access to PPC and required credentials.
                        • Tools: curl, kubectl installed.

                        Policy Agent Setup with PPC

                        Follow these instructions as a guide for understanding specific inputs for Policy Agent integrating with PPC:

                        1. Obtain the Datastore Key Fingerprint

                          To retrieve the fingerprint for your Policy Agent:

                          curl -k -H "Authorization: Bearer ${TOKEN}" -X POST https://${HOST}/pty/v2/pim/datastores/1/export/keys  -H "Content-Type: application/json" --data '{
                            "algorithm": "RSA-OAEP-256",
                            "description": "example-key-from-kms",
                            "pem": "-----BEGIN PUBLIC KEY-----\nABC123... ...890XYZ\n-----END PUBLIC KEY-----"
                          }'
                          

                          Sample Output:

                          {"uid":"1","algorithm":"RSA-OAEP-256","fingerprint":"4c:46:d8:05:35:2e:eb:39:4d:39:8e:6f:28:c3:ab:d3:bc:9e:7a:cb:95:cb:b1:8e:b5:90:21:0f:d3:2c:0b:27","description":"example-key-from-kms"}
                          

                          Record the fingerprint value and configure it as the PTY_DATASTORE_KEY for the Policy Agent.

                        2. Retrieve the PPC CA Certificate

                          To obtain the CA certificate from PPC:

                          kubectl -n api-gateway get secret ingress-certificate-secret -o jsonpath='{.data.ca\.crt}' | base64 -d > CA.pem
                          

                          Use the CA.pem that was returned as described in Policy Agent Installation.

                        3. Configure the PPC Address

                          Use the PPC address in place of the ESA IP address wherever required in your configuration.

                        Log Forwarder Setup with PPC

                        • The Log Forwarder will proceed without certificates and will print a warning if PtyEsaCaServerCert and PtyEsaClientCertificatesSecretId are not provided.
                        • No additional certificate or CA configuration is needed for PPC.

                        Troubleshooting

                        Protector Lambda fails with “AWS KMS Decrypt failed”

                        Symptom:

                        After a successful Policy Agent run and layer update, the Protector Lambda returns:

                        {
                          "body": "{\"error_msg\":\"Failed to open decoder: rpdecode decrypt failure: dek callback failed: AWS KMS Decrypt failed: \",\"success\":false}",
                          "isBase64Encoded": false,
                          "statusCode": 400
                        }
                        

                        The Protector Lambda logs show:

                        [SEVERE] [utils.cpp:185] AWS KMS Decrypt failed:
                        

                        Cause:

                        The public key configured in the PPC/ESA datastore does not match the KMS key pair used by the Policy Agent. The policy package is encrypted with the public key stored in the datastore. If that key does not correspond to the KMS key pair whose private key is used for decryption, the Protector Lambda will fail to decrypt the policy.

                        Resolution:

                        1. Identify the KMS key pair used by the Policy Agent (the key ARN configured during pre-configuration).
                        2. Export the public key from that KMS key pair.
                        3. In PPC/ESA, ensure the datastore’s export key is configured with the public key from that same KMS key pair. See Obtain the Datastore Key Fingerprint above.
                        4. Re-run the Policy Agent to generate a new policy package encrypted with the correct key.
                        5. Test the Protector Lambda again.

                        Additional Notes

                          10.3 - Policy Agent - Custom VPC Endpoint Hostname Configuration

                          Custom vpc endpoint hostname configuration

                          The Policy Agent uses default endpoint hostnames to communicate with other AWS services (for example, secretsmanager.amazonaws.com). This configuration will only work in VPCs where Amazon-provided DNS is available (default VPC configuration with private DNS option enabled for the endpoint). If your VPC uses custom DNS, follow the instructions below to configure the Policy Agent Lambda to use custom endpoint hostnames.

                          Identify DNS Hostnames

                          To identify DNS hostnames:

                          1. From AWS console, select VPC > Endpoints.

                          2. Select Secrets Manager endpoint from the list of endpoints.

                          3. Under Details > DNS Names, note the private endpoint DNS names adding https:// at the beginning of the endpoint name.

                            For example, https://vpce-1234-4pzomrye.kms.us-west-1.vpce.amazonaws.com

                          4. Note down DNS names for the KMS and Lambda endpoints:

                            AWS_SECRETSMANAGER_ENDPOINT: https://_________________

                            AWS_KMS_ENDPOINT: https://_________________

                            AWS_LAMBDA_ENDPOINT: https://_________________

                          Update the Policy Agent Lambda configuration

                          To update policy agent lambda configuration:

                          1. From the AWS console, navigate to Lambda, and select the Policy Agent Lambda function.

                          2. Select the Configuration section and choose Environment variables.

                          3. Select Edit and add the following environment variables with the corresponding endpoint URLs recorded in steps 3-4:

                            ParametersValue
                            AWS_SECRETSMANAGER_ENDPOINT_URL<AWS_SECRETS_ENDPOINT>
                            AWS_KMS_ENDPOINT_URL<AWS KMS ENDPOINT>
                            AWS_LAMBDA_ENDPOINT_URL<AWS LAMBDA ENDPOINT>
                          4. Click Save and Run the Lambda. The Lambda will now use endpoints you have just configured.

                          10.4 - Redshift Cross-Account Configuration

                          Configure Cloud Protect in a different account from the Redshift cluster

                          Cross-Account Configuration

                          The following figure illustrates the Protegrity Redshift Integration architecture when Protegrity Solution is installed on separate from Amazon Redshift Cluster Account.

                          Redshift Account IAM Configuration

                          This step creates Redshift IAM role with permissions to assume role in separate account.

                          Create Redshift IAM policy:

                          1. Login to the AWS account that hosts the Amazon Redshift cluster.

                          2. In the AWS console, access Services > IAM and click Policies.

                          3. Click Create Policy.

                          4. Select the JSON tab and paste the following JSON snippet:

                            { "Version": "2012-10-17", "Statement": [ { "Effect": "Allow", "Action": [ "sts:AssumeRole" ], "Resource": "<DBRoleARN>" } ] }
                            
                          5. Replace the resource value with DBRoleARN recorded in Create IAM Account Role

                          6. Click Review policy to continue.

                          7. Enter a name for the policy.

                          8. Click Create Policy.

                          9. Record the policy name.

                            Redshift IAM Policy Name: ___________________

                          Create Redshift IAM Role

                          This step creates Redshift IAM role with permissions to assume role in separate account.

                          Create Redshift IAM Role:

                          1. Login to the AWS account that hosts the Amazon Redshift cluster.

                          2. In the AWS console, access Services > IAM and click Roles.

                          3. Click Create Role.

                          4. Select AWS Service as the trusted entity type, then select Redshift use case from the list of services.

                          5. Select Redshift – Customizable from the use case section.

                          6. Continue by clicking Next:Permissions.

                          7. Filter the list and search for the policy recorded in the step above (Redshift IAM Policy Name).

                          8. Click the Next:Tags button to continue to the next step.

                          9. Click the Next:Review button to continue.

                          10. Enter a role name, such as Redshift2ProtegrityRole.

                          11. Click Create Role.

                          12. Record role ARN:

                            RedshiftIAMRoleARN: ____________________

                          Attach IAM Role to Redshift Cluster

                          This step creates Redshift IAM role with permissions to assume role in separate account.

                          Attach IAM role to the Redshift cluster:

                          1. Login to AWS Console.

                          2. Access Amazon Redshift and select your cluster.

                          3. Select Properties > Cluster Permissions > Manage IAM Roles.

                          4. Select RedshiftIAMRoleARN configured in the step above and click Associate IAM role.

                          5. Save the changes.

                          6. After saving the changes it may take couple of minutes until the cluster IAM role is fully configured.

                          7. You can check configuration status by navigating back to the cluster IAM role settings.

                          8. The status field next to the IAM role will show in-sync once the role is configured.

                          Defining Redshift External Functions

                          The external function for cross-account differs slightly from the reference material in this document. The function requires two roles to be specified. The following is an example of the modified function definition.

                          CREATE OR REPLACE EXTERNAL FUNCTION demo_schema.pty_unprotect_deName(varchar)
                          RETURNS varchar
                          VOLATILE
                          LAMBDA 'ProtectFunctionProductionAlias'
                          IAM_ROLE '<RedshiftIAMRoleARN>,<DBRoleARN>;
                          

                          Replace <ProtectFunctionProductionAlias> with the value recorded in Install through CloudFormation Replace <RedshiftIAMRoleARN> with the value recorded in Create Redshift IAM Role Replace <DBRoleARN> with the value recorded in Create IAM Account Role

                          10.5 - Sample Redshift External Function

                          Sample redshift external function definitions

                          Sample Redshift External Function

                          Method: Tokenization

                          Type: ALPHA

                           

                          Redshift Data Types

                          Redshift Max Size

                          Protegrity Max Size

                          VARCHAR

                          4K (4,096 bytes)

                          4K (4,096 bytes)

                          CHAR

                           

                           

                           

                          External Function Sample Definitions:

                          CREATE EXTERNAL FUNCTION PTY_PROTECT_ALPHA ( val varchar )
                          RETURNS varchar
                          VOLATILE lambda
                          '<replace_with_protect_function_name>:Production' iam_role 'arn:aws:iam::<REPLACE_WITH_YOUR_AWS_ACCOUNT>:role/<REPLACE_WITH_IAM_ROLE_NAME>';
                          

                           

                          Sample EF Calls:

                          SELECT PTY_PROTECT_ALPHA ('Hello World');
                          
                          SELECT PTY_UNPROTECT_ALPHA('rfDtw sLMJK');
                          

                           

                           

                          Method: Tokenization

                          Type: NUMERIC

                           

                          Redshift Data Types

                          Redshift Max Size

                          Protegrity Max Size

                          DECIMAL

                          4K (4,096 bytes)

                          4K (4,096 bytes)

                          INTEGER

                          BIGINT

                           

                           

                          External Function Sample Definitions:

                          CREATE OR REPLACE EXTERNAL FUNCTION PTY_PROTECT_NUMERIC ( val int )
                          RETURNS int
                          VOLATILE lambda
                          '<replace_with_protect_function_name>:Production' iam_role 'arn:aws:iam::<REPLACE_WITH_YOUR_AWS_ACCOUNT>:role/<REPLACE_WITH_IAM_ROLE_NAME>';
                          

                           

                          Sample EF Calls:

                          SELECT PTY_PROTECT_NUMERIC (2147483647);
                          
                          SELECT PTY_UNPROTECT_NUMERIC(-12344556564);
                          

                          10.6 - Configuring Regular Expression to Extract Policy Username

                          Extract the policy username from the AWS identity.

                          Configuring Regular Expression to Extract Policy Username

                          Cloud Protect Lambda Function exposes USERNAME_REGEX configuration to allow extraction of policy username from user in the request.

                          • USERNAME_REGEX Lambda Environment configuration

                            The USERNAME_REGEX configuration can be used to extract policy username from user in the request. The following are allowed values for USERNAME_REGEX:

                            • 1 - Default build-in regular expression is used:

                              ^arn:aws:(?:iam|sts)::[0-9]{12}:(?:role|user|group|assumed\-role|federated\-user)\/([\w\/+=,.\-]{1,1024}|[\w\/+=,.\-@]{1,1024})(?:@[a-zA-Z0-9\-]{1,320}(?:\.\w+)+)?$
                              
                            • ^User regex$ - Custom regex with one capturing group. This group is used to extract the username. Examples below show different regular expression values and the resulting policy user.

                          USERNAME_REGEX

                          User in the request

                          Effective Policy User

                          Not Set

                          arn:aws:iam::123456789012:user/juliet.snow

                          arn:aws:iam::123456789012:user/juliet.snow

                          arn:aws:sts::123456789012:assumed-role/TestSaml

                          arn:aws:sts::123456789012:assumed-role/TestSaml

                          1

                          arn:aws:iam::123456789012:user/juliet.snow

                          juliet.snow

                          arn:aws:sts::123456789012:assumed-role/TestSaml

                          TestSaml

                          ^arn:aws:(?:iam|sts)::[0-9]{12}:((?:role|user|group|assumed-role|federated-user).*)$
                          

                          arn:aws:iam::123456789012:user/juliet.snow

                          user/juliet.snow

                          arn:aws:sts::123456789012:assumed-role/TestSaml

                          assumed-role/TestSaml

                          10.7 - Associating ESA Data Store With Cloud Protect Agent

                          Configure ESA data store for Policy Agent.

                          Associating ESA Data Store With Cloud Protect Agent

                          ESA controls which policy is deployed to protector using concept of data store. A data store may contain a list of IP addresses identifying servers allowed to pull the policy associated with that specific data store. Data store may also be defined as default data store, which allows any server to pull the policy, provided it does not belong to any other data stores. Node registration occurs when the policy server (in this case the policy agent) makes a policy request to ESA, where the agent’s IP address is identified by ESA.

                          Policy agent lambda source IP address used for node registration on ESA depends on ESA hubcontroller configuration ASSIGN_DATASTORE_USING_NODE_IP and the PTY_ADDIPADDRESSHEADER configuration exposed by the agent lambda.

                          The Lambda service uses multiple network interfaces, internal network interface with ephemeral IP range of 169.254.x.x and external network interface with IP range of the VPC subnet the Lambda is associated with. By default, when agent lambda is contacting ESA to register node for policy download, ESA uses agent Lambda VPC IP address. This default behavior is caused by the default ESA hubcontroller configuration ASSIGN_DATASTORE_USING_NODE_IP=false and agent default configuration PTY_ADDIPADDRESSHEADER=yes.

                          In some cases, when there is a proxy server between the ESA and agent lambda, the desirable ESA configuration is ASSIGN_DATASTORE_USING_NODE_IP=true. and PTY_ADDIPADDRESSHEADER=no which will cause the ESA to use proxy server IP address.

                          The table below shows how the hubcontroller and agent settings will affect node IP registration on ESA.

                          Agent source IPAgent VPC subnet IPProxy IPESA config - ASSIGN_DATASTORE_USING_NODE_IPAgent lambda config - PTY_ADDIPADDRESSHEADERAgent node registration IP
                          169.254.144.8110.1.2.173No Proxytrueyes169.254.144.81
                          trueno10.1.2.173
                          falseyes
                          falseno
                          169.254.144.8110.1.2.17334.230.42.110trueyes169.254.144.81
                          trueno34.230.42.110
                          falseyes
                          falseno